Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

If the election were held today

By CosmicConservative
... and the RCP rolling aggregation of polls predicts the state outcomes... Obama wins the electoral vote 294 - 244, a 50 vote margin. IF there is a 1 point shift in the polls in Romney's direction that changes to: Obama wins the electoral vote 277 - 261, a 16 vote margin. Close, but still an Obama victory. IF there is a 2 point shift in the polls in Romney's direction that changes to: Romney wins the electoral vote 271 - 265, a razor-thin victory that will likely lead to legal challenges. This would still not be enough to give Romney Ohio. To get Ohio Romney needs a further shift of half a point (.4 actually). Let's say there is a 2.5 point shift in the polls in Romney's direction. That would mean: Romney wins the electoral vote 295 - 243, an almost exact reversal of where things actually are today. Is it possible to get that much of a swing in less than three weeks? Yes, but it is highly unlikely. It would seem Romney's best shot is to abandon Ohio, focus on Wisconsin, New Hampshire, Iowa and Virginia and hope he can withstand the legal challenges. Perhaps he can pick up an elector from Maine as well. At this point I would say that if Romney can manage to pick up Ohio, it is hard to see him losing. There is a way to win without Ohio, but that will make for one hair-raising, nail-biting evening of watching election returns come in.

Comments (20)

Drax
You gotta stop looking at the polls that way. If you don't take into account the "undecided," then WHATEVER conclusion you draw will be meaningless in a close race. If there's a 3-5 point undecided, the majority of that will go Romney's way, resulting in a 1-3 point swing. So, we're ALREADY at the point of Romney winning. The question now is "By how much?" (Unless something changes at the next debate. And, somehow, I don't see it going Obama's way...)
JSullins
Optimism can be refreshing. I am probably more in the "resigned to Obama the Sequel" camp, however.
CosmicConservative
Drax, if I am going to factor in undecideds, then I should factor them in according to some factual values that might be available for how undecideds are breaking. Unfortunately that's not possible because those voters are still undecided. But what we CAN do is look historically at how they break. Historically a LARGE break would be 2-1 in favor of one candidate. Let's say undecideds do break 2-1 for Romney. Now let's go see what that means: Virginia, currently Obama, shifts to Romney (13 electoral votes) Ohio, currently Obama, stays Obama by a hair New Hampshire, currently Obama, shifts to Romney by a hair (4 e.v.) Wisconsin, currently Obama, stays Obama by more than .5% Michigan, currently Obama, stays Obama by almost 1% Pennsylvania, currently Obama, stays Obama by a healthy margin Iowa, currently Obama, stays Obama by a hair. Nevada, currently Obama, stays Obama by almost 1% So, a 2 - 1 shift of undecideds nets Romney Virginia and New Hampshire, for a total of 17 electoral votes, meaning Obama wins by 277 - 261. So, if undecideds are going to win this election for Romney, how far will they have to break for Romney? The answer to this is tricky because in some of the "toss-up" states Obama is already at more than 49% and Romney is still stuck around 45%. For undecideds to throw those states to Romney would require an unprecedented 10 or 20 - 1 break for Romney. Which brings us to Ohio. Because Ohio still has a substantial undecided population, it is the best shot for Romney to pick up in this manner. In fact it only requires a 3-1 break of undecideds to Romney. That's a whole lot better than 10-1 or 20-1, but would you want to bet your mortgage on 75% of all remaining undecideds breaking to Romney?
CosmicConservative
The inescapable conclusion from this analysis is that for Romney to win this election, he will have to move people from Obama to Romney, undecideds are not going to do it. Or else Romney voters are going to have to make up that 1 - 2% deficit in pure voter enthusiasm alone, meaning the Romney GOTV effort will have to beat the Obama GOTV effort substantially. I suspect that is currently the strategy of the Romney team. Get the biggest break of undecideds as possible and out-hustle Obama by 1 - 2 % in Ohio, Iowa, Colorado, Virginia and New Hampshire. That's probably what I'd be doing.
Dadman
You Negative Neds are just wrong. You can crunch the numbers until you're crossed eyed and depressed, but it won't change the fact Romney is going to win. I feel it just as I felt an Obama victory in March of 2008.
CosmicConservative
Dadman, I am getting more optimistic as time goes on, but I would have been a whole lot more optimistic if Romney had performed better in the last debate. I think it's possible, but right now I think this is going to boil down to which team has the better feet on the ground on election day. In fact, it could come down to the weather.
CosmicConservative
One thing to consider if you are going to be optimistic is that Obama's campaign has to be running the same numbers I am and coming to the same conclusions. That could well lull them into a sense of inevitability and they might not be as motivated as Romney's team. That's possible. It's happened before. That's how Bush almost lost Florida.
Dadman
And I think the difference will be the enthusiam of the Republican/conservative base and the fact that the polls are not accurately reflecting Romney's support...
Dadman
Perhaps I'm being overly optimistic. I'm prepared to eat crow if I'm wrong...as long as it is fried with a side of barbecue sauce. ;)
JSullins
EVerything is better fried! Now... how much batter do we need for say, a second-term liberal administration?
Dadman
In a second-term liberal adminstration batter is likely to be banned or taxed into oblivion...
Drax
What do you mean that you'd feel better if Romney did better in the last debate? He did fripping GREAT. The only reason it seems as if he didn't do so great is that he actually had an opponent in this one (two if we're being accurate). Again, as I stated just after the debate - what would the takeaway? What would everyone be talking about? Libya. The moderator. They're not talking about how badly Obama beat Romney, because he didn't. He barely won by the polling, but the internals were DEVASTATING for Obama. Romney won on EVERY issue - economy, foreign policy, taxes, and even who "looked more Presidential." And Romney KILLED among Luntz's group. He's picked up a point nationwide with 3 day rolling polls. Let's see where we are tomorrow and Monday. And, try your analysis with Romney getting 75-80% of the undecided.
Drax
The only issue with Romney's performance might be the attacks/issues he "left on the table." That happens. It always happens. You have the time you have and, it's all from memory. What's IMPORTANT is what was actually said - not what he DIDN'T say. You didn't see it. You need to actually watch the debate from beginning to end. Romney did quite well. And, he pinned Obama down on his "day after" remark on Libya for MONDAY. I expect that this lie will come back to haunt Obama in a big way on Monday.
Drax
And, just for emphasis: "Romney takes 48 percent support in Ohio, edging President Obama at 47, in the new poll conducted by American Research Group (ARG)... And in Colorado, likely voters went for Romney 50 to 46 over Obama, in ARG’s poll. Romney soundly outpaced Obama among female voters in the state, taking 51 percent support against Obama at 45." http://pjmedia.com/tatler/2012/10/18/hey-obama-your-firewall-is-on-fire/ There are polls where Obama is losing a significant % of the Jewish vote, 10-15% of the black vote, and has closed the gap significantly with the Hispanic vote. (And, the gender gap FAVORS Romney by 8% or so since men hugely favor Romney and women are continuing to desert Obama.) Things are good and looking better every day.
Drax
Oops. Apparently the linked Colorado/Ohio poll was October 9. Hotair ran correction....sigh.
jussayin'
New Pennsylvania poll shows Romney ahead. Another Obamster by the same amount. I don't think PA is that firmly in Obamster's paws. NJ is also in play. Women are moving toward Romney in a decent amount. The Obamsters have bought a place in Hawaii. The venue for election night is an indoor hall, much smaller than the park used last time. Not exactly sounding like they are all that confident with their chances of a second term. Obama may have hurt his chances even more by his comment on Comedy Central, saying the deaths of 4 people isn't optimal. Think that is going to fire up people? Obama has had two women in his regime who have called out his administration as being a "hostile workplace" for women. Think that will bring in the women's votes? There are just too many things against Obamster. Another is this College system that uses various issue data to predict the election outcome. They have been right for over 20 years now, they have Romney by 75%. Anything can happen, but there just seems to be too much going Romney's way including the overall swing since the first debate, that is just doesn't feel like a repeat for Obamster is going to happen.
CosmicConservative
Romney's 2 point advantage in the Rasmussen daily tracking poll has disappeared and they are now tied at 48% each.
Dadman
Why are you actively looking for the dark cloud in the silver lining? Romney is going to win (finger crossed :) )
CosmicConservative
Dadman, I suspected that Romney's debate bounce was not going to be permanent. However, on the bright side, I do think Romney is positioned well to clobber Obama in the foreign policy debate. Except that I expect Obama to lie like a yellow dog to avoid getting pinned down by pesky little facts. I dunno why I'm so negative. I suppose it's not strictly restricted to politics. I should try to be more optimistic about things I suppose.
jussayin'
The Obamster is trying to throw the CIA and State Department under the bus. Did you notice that more and more things are leaking out contradicting just about everything Obama has said about the intelligence on Lybia? Gallop polling shows R 52, O 45. Duh One is will soon be Duh Once.