Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The case against Lance...

By CosmicConservative
... is finally being presented by the USADA.
The U.S. Anti-Doping Agency says 11 of Lance Armstrong's former teammates testified against him in its investigation of the cyclist, revealing "the most sophisticated, professionalized and successful doping program that sport has ever seen." USADA will deliver its reasoned decision against Armstrong later Wednesday, a summary of the facts it used to hand him a lifetime suspension and erase his seven Tour de France titles. In a news release previewing the decision, USADA CEO Travis Tygart said it would include more than 1,000 pages of evidence. He listed 11 of Armstrong's former teammates, including George Hincapie, Floyd Landis and Tyler Hamilton, as among those providing evidence that led to the sanction. Armstrong spokesman Mark Fabiani declined immediate comment, referring to a letter the cyclist's attorney sent to USADA on Tuesday. Read more:
Eleven of his teammates testified against him. That would be comparable to the entire starting lineup of the San Francisco Giants plus a reliever or two and a pinch hitter testifying against Barry Bonds. Ouch.

Comments (15)

Boyd
That's testimony. While I'm certainly not accusing them of lying (and one would think, necessarily, conspiracy), it's well within the realm of possibility that they're lying about their former teammate. That's why it's imperative that USADA shows some actual evidence. Otherwise, they're just a buncha hacks, IMNSHO.
Drax
It won't matter what evidence is proffered. The Armstrong loyalists will still defend him. Sigh.
Boyd
But that's the point, Drax. The evidence is *all* "so-and-so said" or "such-and-such wrote in an email." That's not evidence, that's what you say when you don't *have* any evidence. Listen, if they had more than the word of people who have something to gain from tearing down Armstrong (the satisfaction of tearing down someone they don't like, the ability to keep racing when they've done *exactly* what they're accusing Armstrong of doing, and so forth), I could see pursuing all this. So we have a huge mound of hard, physical evidence from over more than a dozen years that Armstrong wasn't doping, and we have a dozen or two people who all say, "Nuh-uh! He did too!" without a single. solitary. piece. of. physical. evidence. to support their contention. I have a hard time buying it. I'm not an Armstrong apologist, but I've had enough smoke and sunshine blown up my butt over the last four years that I can't take more of the same from USADA about Armstrong or anyone else.
CosmicConservative
Boyd, people have been routinely convicted of serious crimes in court based solely on eye-witness evidence. In fact eye-witness evidence is considered one of the strongest forms of evidence against criminals. Are you suggesting that our legal system is inadequate in that regard?
Dadman
And eyewitness evidence is also notoriously unreliable. I agree with Boyd. :)
CosmicConservative
I can't help but think if you were on the jury and eleven eye witnesses swore under oath that the defendant was the guy who walked into the convenience store and shot the clerk that you'd convict. If the eye witnesses were co-workers and friends of the defendant I think you'd throw away the key.
Drax
I swear. 11 former teammates, some of whom admit to their own participation in the PED conspiracy - under oath, give eye witness testimony as to Armstrong's participation and that ain't enough. That's sad. All it takes to put a man in jail for decades for rape is for a woman to say "I said no" when the man said it was consensual sex. All it takes for a man to go to jail for armed robbery is for the victim to say "He did it." But eleven former teammates saying "Lance did it," ain't enough. How about 26? Is that enough? Because that's how many affidavits the USADA submitted yesterday. The documents which show more than a million dollars in payments to Michele Ferrari, convicted in 2004 for sporting fraud for advising cyclists on doping, that ain't enough either. As I said. It doesn't matter what evidence comes out, it won't be enough for Armstrong loyalists.
Boyd
I could go on a separate rant about our so-called "justice system," but that's not the subject here. I've said my peace above, but I'll merely point out that you're consistently overlooking the reward that USADA is giving almost all of those testifying against Armstrong, Drax. As far as I can tell, none of them are saying this because it's the right thing to do, they're saying it because they're essentially being paid to say it. There's a big difference there.
CosmicConservative
Boyd, virtually every criminal case of significant importance uses "plea bargain" deals to get cooperation from witnesses. So those witnesses are "rewarded" for their testimony with reduced sentences or even freedom. Yet the vast majority of Americans would take 26 eye witness accounts of a murder as more than sufficient evidence. I think it is interesting that people will impugn the integrity of 26 athletes in the effort to save the integrity of 1. I dunno, sometimes the math just doesn't make sense.
CosmicConservative
From the USADA document:
SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE THAT CORROBORATES LANCE ARMSTRONG’S DOPING VIOLATIONS… p139 A. Armstrong’s Blood Test Results During the 2009 and 2010 Tours de France are Consistent with His Continued Use of Blood Doping…p140 B. 1999 Tour de France Samples…p142 C. 2001 Tour of Switzerland Samples…p144
So apparently the USADA scientists believe they have blood test results from four races that are consistent with doping. So it's not all a bunch of disgruntled rivals trying to tear Lance down. And this:
E. How Lance Armstrong and the USPS Team Avoided Positive Drug Tests... 129 1. Avoiding testers during window of detection…p131 2. Using undetectable substances and methods…p135 3. Understanding limitations to the testing methods…p137 4. Use of saline infusions and micro-doping of EPO…p139
... which go to my earlier points about passing tests not being reliable proof of compliance. If you manage to avoid the blood testing while the evidence is in your blood, it's pretty easy to pass a drug test. Anyway, I think this will be my last Lance post. I have very slowly and deliberately come to the conclusion that Lance is a sophisticated and disciplined cheater who gamed the system and won for his entire career, but whose cheating eventually caught up with him. Sure, I might be wrong, and I still greatly admire Lance for his many charitable activities, his triumph over his own cancer and his competitive fire and determination. As Drax has said repeatedly, and as much of this testimony seems to confirm, for this period, much like the "steroid era" in baseball, it appears that if you wanted to compete in cycling, you cheated. Period. The massive evidence of drug use and other cheating techniques employed by virtually every team, doctor and competitor is pretty overwhelming. My personal take-away is that Lance probably would have been just as dominant if nobody cheated. He really just leveled the playing field. But it's still cheating.
Dadman
Relax guys. My defense of Lance is somewhat TIC. Given the evidence I have to admit he is likely guilty of cheating. But, like Boyd, I still harbor some doubts. His accusers are not friends of Lance, not paragons of virtue, a few are proven cheaters (by virtue of failed drug tests; I guess they didn't learn the cheating science well enough from their cheating mentor, Lance), and seem to have something to gain by testifying against Armstrong. There are aspects of the USADA case that just don't smell right. Of course, other aspects of their case are quite compelling. BTW, you could accuse any athlete that's never failed a drug test of being a diabolical cheating mastermind that's just too smart to get caught. I find all the reasons the USADA gives to explain why Lance has never officially failed a drug test almost humorous and not entirely realistic. Armstrong was tested thousands of times over the course of his career and never failed. The 'scientific evidence' the USADA cites is sketchy and likely would not be admitted in a court of law. But that's all the 'scientific evidence' they have. And I still find it interesting that many of his accusers, cyclists who apparently learned the cheating craft from the master cheater himself, were caught cheating through positive testing. I guess they are slow learners. But, 26 witnesses and suspicious payments to shady characters, etc. are difficult things to dismiss. Lance, unfortunately, is probably guilty of doping. Like Cosmic, I still admire his accomplishments, too. Beating stage 4 testicular cancer, and helping others Live Strong in the face of enormous challenges, are still his greatest victories in my book...
CosmicConservative
Yeah, I'm not anti-Lance. And I'm sad about all this. I do think there is something to the notion that Drax keeps mentioning that for much of the 90s and the first decade of 2000 if you wanted to compete at the top level in most, if not all, sports, you either had to be a true freak of nature, or you cheated. There is so much evidence piled up from sport after sport that it's hard to dismiss the idea that even athletes with strong moral codes who would fight the temptation for years might finally succumb due to the sheer realization of reality. I hope things are cleaner now. But I still hear that cycling is a mess.
Drax
Let me make my position clear. Lance was a cyclist. That was how he had decided to feed himself and his family. According to one of the witnesses against him, there came a point, after continually losing, that Lance complained about the fact that they were getting beat by people who used PED's or otherwise enhanced their natural physical abilities and decided that, as the adage goes, "If you can't beat them, join them." I can't blame him. Don't, really. He believed that he either gave up his dream of racing for a living or he joined the "cheaters" and raced them on, to his mind, would then be a level playing field. The doesn't, however, color my conclusion that he did, IN FACT, "cheat." This isn't a "he said/she said" situation, no matter how anyone tries to frame it as one. (And, unless, like Marion Barry, the actor is caught - either in the act or captured on video - then any witness testimony is ALWAYS "he said/she said.") No, the witnesses named the Doctor who supplied the drugs and the information on how to avoid positive testing. Financial payments of over a MILLION DOLLARS were identified from Armstrong to that doctor - a doctor who had been CONVICTED of supplying CYCLISTS with information on how to avoid positive tests. This is as close to an open-and-shut case as one would ever find absent the aforementioned "caught on camera or in the act" type of "evidence." Nor does the fact that I hold Armstrong morally blameless for joining the "cheaters" prevent me from seeing the actions that he took to prevent anyone from IDENTIFYING him as one. He called them "liars" in public and through national media. He threatened some of them according to the testimony. He, much like Bill Clinton in the Lewinski matter, attempted to DESTROY those who attempted to "out" him in order to SAVE HIS OWN ASS. And, does anyone believe that these people came forward voluntarily? No. Not for the most part. They knew (as this thread evidences) that they would be faced with the fanatical devotion of Lance's fans as well as the might of Lance himself (with his huge megaphone and his fat, fat wallet) as well as that of his corporation. Like Paula Jones, they didn't come forward until they had no other choice (for the most part). Like CC, I stand astonished at the willingness of Lance's fanatical followers in their willingness to see a conspiracy of TWENTY-SIX liars against Lance so to avoid the uncomfortable thought that Lance could have been, like almost every top-level cyclist, "cheating." Shocked at their willingness to call all these people liars. Their willingness to believe that the financial documents were manufactured so to reflect over a million dollars flowing from Lance to a doctor who had been convicted of the very thing of which Lance is supposed to have done. Why? What is there about this man which would cause such IRRATIONAL devotion? Is it because he won seven titles? That should be the first warning sign that he WAS a cheater. It should make any cycling enthusiast ANGRY that he cheated his way to those titles, rather than engender any devotion for his having done so. Is it because of the good works he has done for cancer? What does that have to do with ANYTHING as it relates to the allegations that he cheated his way to success? At best, we can say that he was a good man (as evidenced by his foundation) who had no moral qualms against doing what he felt was necessary to level the playing field - even if what was necessary was considered to be "cheating." At worst, he was an immoral asshole who did what was necessary for fame and glory, then, once he had achieved that, he started a foundation for cancer research (something which he had in intimate interest in pursuing) because that's how ex-athletes kept the money, fame, and perks rolling after their days of competition are over. But, his MOTIVATIONS are irrelevant. He either did or he did not. Either one accepts the evidence or one does not. But, to excuse his actions or to ignore the evidence because of motivations which are ENTIRELY imagined by those who give life to such excuse (as we cannot get inside his mind or heart) is simply inexcusable.
Drax
Here's a pretty good breakdown on how Lance used bribery and intimidation to keep his secret. http://www.nydailynews.com/sports/more-sports/zone-lance-armstrong-bully-downfall-article-1.1188512 As I've stated, I give Lance NO slack because he did "good things" outside of racing. We haven't a clue as to WHY he set up his foundation - whether it was simply to "do good," or because he had cancer and wanted a cure for an entirely selfish manner, or it was a way for him to keep his fame and glory after his days of racing were over. He gets no pass from me simply because his foundation has had good results as I find it just as easy to believe that his INTENT in starting the foundation was selfish as it was altruistic - especially in light of how he treated others in an effort to protect himself against the doping allegations.