The new narrative
By CosmicConservativeEven the lefty blogs are now routinely suggesting that Obama's debate problems were due to the fact that Obama has never had to deal with an actual substantive challenge to his self-professed awesomeness before. Of course here on this blog and in much of the conservative blogosphere the "empty suit, affirmative action, do-nothing narcissist" meme has been pretty much accepted as a fair description of Barack Obama. But now I'm seeing similar statements from the left.
Let's say it's true. Let's say that Barack Obama, for the first time in his entire life, has suddenly been confronted with meaningful, hurtful, substantive criticism and ridicule from people whose opinion actually matters to him. Like Bill Maher or Snoop Dogg. What is Obama's likely reaction?
It is said that it is in adversity that we truly learn about ourselves. What is Obama learning right now?
If, as has been the preferred narrative on the right, Obama truly is an utter narcissist with delusions of grandeur, then he is likely to simply get angry and go into denial. That would mean that Obama will probably conclude that he simply needs to go after Romney with every gimmick and lie he can scrape together between now and the next debate. That would mean he will probably hurl "47%!" and "Bain!" and "$5 trillion tax cut!" at Romney repeatedly, waiting for the crushing weight of public opinion to reduce Romney to a puddle of goo. The goal would be to try to destroy Romney because the campaign would have become something personal to Obama.
If, however, Obama has more to him than being a purely ideological narcissist, then he might take the approach of trying to out-Romney Romney and actually prepare for the debate by learning what his administration actually has been doing and searching for actual substantive chinks in Romney's armor. If so then he will probably try to undercut Romney's criticisms by zeroing in on every possible detail of Romney's career as governor or any possible inconsistencies in Romney's promises from the primary campaign to now. He might focus on Romneycare, or statements Romney's made about social security or medicare. The goal then would be to try to undermine Romney's appeal to independents and restore Obama's slim lead in the polls.
I hope Romney's getting prepared for both of these scenarios. I think the first scenario is better for Romney because if he's gotten under Obama's skin deeply enough, he could conceivably goad Obama into some serious mistakes. If Obama takes the second route, it's going to be more difficult for Romney to repeat this week's performance, but if Romney is prepared enough and clever enough, he can, I hope, at least maintain his momentum.
I've always been of the opinion that Obama is not nearly as smart as people think he is, he's not nearly as good an orator as people think he is, and that he is truly a pretty textbook narcissist who simply can't endure mockery or ridicule. I suppose in this next debate we will find out once and for all exactly how accurate that analysis is.
Comments (2)