Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Your debate thoughts?

By CosmicConservative
No, I didn't watch a split second of it. Based on my experience with my observations of professional sports, if I had accidentally switched over to the debate for a nano-second, Mitt Romney would have projectile vomited all over the audience. I'll read the transcripts and watch some Youtube videos. But what say those of you who did watch?

Comments (28)

Dadman
Only watched some of it. I share your cursing powers and was concerned Romney would snort a loogie out of his nose the moment I tuned in. I did like what I saw...
CosmicConservative
Well, the reviews seem positive towards Romney, but I expect those will slowly morph in Obama's favor over the next week.
Dadman
Well, the MSM will certainly try to spin it for Obama, but it was evidently such a blowout even MSNBC is declaring Romney the clear victor...at least in the moments right after the debate.
Annie
Romney wiped the floor with Obama. My favorite part: "President Obama, I have five boys, I'm used to not hearing the truth. You can't just keep repeating something over and over to make it true." There were TONS of other good ones, but as the Mother of two boys, that one had me rolling on the floor.
Drax
Watched all of it. Romney kicked Obama's skinny butt. In "style," Romney looked more Presidential. He addressed Obama eye-to-eye when he outright called him a liar - TWICE. (Effectively, too. Once he said something like, "I have 5 boys, so I have some experience with someone saying something untrue over and over in hopes that it will ultimately be believed." (In rebuttal to Obama constantly saying that Romney was asking for 5 trillion in tax cuts) Then, once saying something like, "... as President, you're entitled to your own house and your own plane, but you're not entitled to your own facts." Romney looked upbeat and energetic - like he was enjoying himself and was in full command of his facts. Obama looked, and sounded, tired, ill-prepared, and, by the end of the debate - beaten. Romney kept eye contact with Obama even while battering him. Obama seldom looked at Romney and, while being chastised (no other word, really) by Romney, kept his head down and "smirked" quite a lot. The word most used to describe his demeanor I think is "peevish." Romney had full command of the facts at his fingertips and used them effectively. Obama frequently was meandering. (Bill Maher tweeted something along the lines of "OMG, he DOES need a teleprompter!" Romney was constantly on the attack, Obama on the defensive. But, Romney, not once, came off as "mean" while on the offense while Obama frequently came off as boorish while on the defensive. There were no "great debate moments." Romney not only won, Obama lost. By this I mean that the DISTANCE between the winner and loser was far greater than ANY debate I've ever seen. As Romney piled up points, Obama kept retreating (looking more and more meek as time went on). As one commentator said, if it had been a boxing match, it would have been stopped after the first round. But, it wasn't. And Romney kept hammering him for 14 more rounds. It was frapping GREAT. And, next, we get to see Ryan beat the hell out of Biden. That will be fun!
Annie
And how about, "I've been in business 25 years and have no idea what you are talking about." Seriously, Romney took Obama for a ride on the roof of his car!
JSullins
I always love when Biden speaks... and I have this mental image of Obama campaign workers cringing every time he opens his mouth... hehe. But, what I want to know is (I didn't watch the debate) what is all this business about big bird?
CosmicConservative
I didn't watch the debate but piecing it together from comments it appears that either Jim Lehrer or Obama tried to demonize Romney as a PBS killer, and Romney's response was "I love Big Bird!" Something like that. Biden is still a national politician because he "handles well". In other words, when his aides and campaign staff have adequate time to prepare him and load him up with stuff to say, he can regurgitate it fairly well. As such he can come across as a reasonably intelligent guy in situations like a planned debate with rules and a moderator who will do his best to keep Biden on script. It is when Biden has to think on his own and react to things in real time that he reveals his complete and utter stupidity. So for Ryan the trick is going to be to force Biden off-script and knock the moderator off-task. If he can do that, Biden will destroy himself. If Ryan just assumes he will defeat Biden through sheer superior mastery of the facts and preparation, he will likely find Biden somewhat more formidable than he might expect.
Drax
The Big Bird thing was brought up by Romney in response to a question about just what he would cut in the budget. One example he gave was along the lines of "I love big bird, but we can't continue supporting PBS." In the VP debate with Palin, Romney stated several things which were factually incorrect which, if Palin had been on the national stage for more than a minute, she could have called him on. Ryan will. And, Biden will LIE. He can't help himself. He's a liar. He will say anything he thinks he can get away with. And, Ryan will call him on it. Mark it down. There will be at least a couple of times where Biden says something which Ryan either expressly calls Biden a liar or implies it so clearly that no one could mistake this meaning. And, he'll back it up. It's going to be an epic ass whooping.
CosmicConservative
I think you meant "Biden stated several things which were factually incorrect" not "Romney"... You may be right. All I know is that I have seen Biden over-perform several times. The recent DNC would be one example.
JSullins
Heh, it's Fox News so what do you expect, but, gotta give them props for this: "Clint Eastwood's empty chair at the Republican National Convention last month mounted a more passionate defense of President Obama's policies and his vision for the country than Obama did last night."
CosmicConservative
JSullins... ouch... of course that sort of thing doesn't speak well to Fox's objectivity... but it's definitely funny.
Jack
Hi guys! I'm the token liberal who drops in here once in a while and comments mostly about the movies I make. (CC and Dadman know what I'm talking about.) I avoid political comments because I know I'm somewhat at risk of getting "piled on" and, at the end of the day, what's the point. :-) That being said, I did watch the debate so I'll give you my summary. (Full disclosure: I am an Obama supporter.) Romney was the clear winner. He did not appear uncomfortable or like a robot as he has often come across. He spoke directly to Obama whereas Obama tended to speak to the audience, Jim Lehrer, or to the camera. Nothing wrong with that per se, but it was the incorrect venue for it; he should've looked his opponent in the eye more often. Also, Obama spent too much time looking down while Romney spoke. We all know that candidates do that because they make notes; it's just that Obama did it too often. Romney stayed on point better than Obama, and came out swinging; he clearly was playing offense. One of the few points Obama scored was on Obamacare, when he, rightly so, stated it was nearly the exact plan as Romneycare. Mitt really had to dance around that issue. There were many topics that Obama could've touched on that he just didn't. An example would be (during the healthcare portion of the debate) Obama could've put Romney on the spot for commenting, just 2 weeks ago on 60 Minutes, that he said people without health insurance don't need it because they can just go to the emergency room. This not only contradicts what he said several years ago (all of which is on tape) but is one of the roots of our healthcare problems. That's just one example. My point being, there is a wide landscape of topics that both men could've used against the other, but Romney was the only one who took advantage of it. From just the little I've heard today concerning the fact-checking, both men were about equally accurate/inaccurate, including a couple huge inaccuracies pointed out by their own camps! Obama's people said Obama was wrong about the growth of healthcare costs over the past 50 years, and Romney's people said Romney was wrong about his healthcare plan included people with pre-existing conditions. Besides pointing out how Obamacare and Romneycare are basically the same, Obama commented about the lack of specifics, and the frequently changing positions of Romney, for which the Governor had no real defense. However, Obama's performance was so lackluster that these points (though accurate) lacked any real punch. Romney came out swinging and scored multiple hits. The media, almost across the board, has declared Mitt the winner of this round. CC, I don't know what comments you are reading about the Big Bird statement, but there was no attack or demonization that I saw. Romney simply stated he would cut funding to PBS and added that he loved Big Bird and that he liked Jim Lehrer too, but thought the federal government didn't need to fund the programming. I walked in and out of the room a couple times so it's possible the topic briefly popped up again later and I missed it, but the only reference to Big Bird I heard is what I stated above. In closing, I'd like to remind everyone that George W was soundly defeated by John Kerry in their first debate. So much so that many pundits thought it was over for Bush. The next two debates clearly went in Bush's favor and we all know what happened after that. I think this debate will help Romney close the gap (probably already has) and, without a doubt, Obama is in trouble. But, I think we can all agree it's far too early to call it.
CosmicConservative
Jack, thanks for posting. Because this is clearly a conservative blog, I know that we sometimes suffer from our own cocoon effect, so it is always nice to get a bit of reality check. I have particularly been guilty of predicting an Obamageddon, which in retrospect is probably just as silly as the "Romney will make your grandparents eat dogfood" commentary from the Left. I need to chill. I had a short exchange on FB yesterday with someone who was raving incoherently about how a Romney victory would throw us into another great depression, and for a moment there I saw a troubling mirror image of my own attitudes. I stand corrected on the Big Bird statement. I had assumed, based on some comments I had seen, and assuming is always a poor rhetorical position to take. For whatever it is worth, after reviewing a number of blogs, both right and left, this morning, it appears that the current gestalt on the debate is that Romney made Obama look weak, unprepared, indecisive and, eventually, defeated. That's good for my team, not so good for yours. But there are two more Presidential and one VP debate to go, and it's still a lifetime away from Nov 6. In the inimitable words of Han Solo, "Great job kid, don't get cocky."
Jack
One good Star Wars quote deserves another. Whether one is conservative or liberal, Republican, Democrat, or independent, we most likely can agree that the wise words of Obi-Wan about Mos Eisley Spaceport can equally apply to American politics. And those words are, "... you will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We must be cautious." :-D
Drax
Jack: We appear to have different memories of the Bush/Kerry debates. It was close. Neither one did all that well. Romney DEMOLISHED Obama. It's not only that Romney was strong, articulate, knowledgeable, aggressive, invigorated, pleasant - it's that Obama was the OPPOSITE of all of those things. The contrast between them was absolutely STUNNING. When we also factor in the expectations most had for each (i.e., that Romney would be stilted and soft with a disadvantage of knowledge as compared to a sitting President while Obama would be an rhetorical genius who had all the facts at his fingers) - the contrast becomes almost unbelievable. This is the absolute worst ass whooping any sitting President has ever taken without even a close second. And, guess what? It ain't gonna get any better. Why? Because Obama's RECORD in foreign policy is just as dismal as is his record in domestic policy. And, the MAIN reason that Obama did so poorly is that he had nowhere safe to retreat. There was no "safe ground" on the economy. All he could do is what he did, appeal to the voters not to look backwards (his opening remarks) but to look forwards. Yeah. And the response from Mitt will be the same as it was last night. "You had 4 years to do all these things you're talking about and didn't. Why should anyone believe that the next 4 years won't be the same as the last?" And, where's the "safe ground" in foreign policy? Iran? Afghanistan? Israel? Iraq? Pakistan? Syria? Europe? Great Britain? Canada even? Mexico? India? China? Russia? There IS no "safe ground" in foreign policy. Only targets of opportunity for Romney to exploit. There isn't a SINGLE country out there about which Obama has a POSITIVE record. And, he has a negative record on most of them - and for some a DISASTEROUSLY negative record. So, ALL he has in the next debate is what he has in his campaign ads. To put up straw men. Lie. Fear monger. Class warfare. Etc. ANYTHING but have the voters actually judge him on WHAT HE HAS DONE. (Or, for that matter, who and what he actually IS.)
Dadman
Jack: Serious question for you. No trap or set-up. I'm genuinely curious. Why are you an Obama supporter? When I look at Obama I see a man who consistently puts ideology over practical solutions that would actually help our floundering economy. I see a man who will say almost anything to score political points and do almost nothing to live up to his own words. Most of all I see an extremely weak leader, both here at home and on the international stage, who continues to proffer policies and 'solutions' that just don't work. Finally, I see a man (and political party - Dems) who have no intention of ending their irresponsible and dangerous levels of spending anytime soon because it's the way they retain their power. The level of modern-day liberal fiscal malfeasance is scary to me. But that's my view. Why do you support Obama?
Jack
Hi Dadman, I know you're not setting me up for a trap; I believe you are genuinely curious. However, since you stated your view of Obama, and Democrats in general, of which I disagree with, there's no point. I think of the Republicans pretty much the same way as you do about the Democrats. We should just leave it at that. CC explained it best with his comparison of Obamageddon vs. "Romney will make your grandparents eat dogfood." Both are silly views. But they can be held by reasonable people. Personally, I think there is a fundamental difference in perception between conservatives and liberals. That's why I very, very rarely make political comments; what's the point? I'm sorry, but that's the most you're going to get out of me on a public, conservative blog. I still hope you'll watch my new film, FATAL CALL (formerly titled CALL ME ON TUESDAY), when it hits the market. I know you liked my last film. I'm living the American Dream but I still need all the viewers I can get. Regardless of one's political views. :-)
CosmicConservative
Yeah, for many, if not most, it's all about the ideology. The world view informs the perception and the perception drives the acceptance of what is and isn't "factual". In the end when two camps can't even decide on what is objectively true, there's really no hope getting them to agree on what to do about things.
Dadman
I'm disappointed, Jack. I shared my view of Obama because that is the 'reality' I see when I observe the political landscape around me. I also know that smart, reasonable people I know personally see an entirely different reality. I could probably guess what you see, but I was hoping you might be willing to share your view of 'reality'. But if you don't want to I do understand. Other than here on this blog I rarely talk politics. It's just too incendiary...
Drax
Jack said: "“Romney will make your grandparents eat dogfood.” Both are silly views. But they can be held by reasonable people" No, Jack. They can't. And, that the who fripping point that Dadman is making. The very notion that "reasonable people" could believe that Romney would "make your grandparents eat dogfood" is absolutely INSANE. No sane person would believe this. No sane person would say this. So, when you say that liberals and conservatives have fundamentally different perceptions, you're correct. They do. Conservatives perceive reality as it exists. Liberals do not perceive reality at all. (We could get into a whole thing about defining "liberal" which would be fruitless. I consider myself to be a liberal - just as I was thirty years ago. But, my views, mostly unchanged fundamentally, now more closely align with what is now called "conservative" and/or "libertarian" than the abomination of a political philosophy which now poses as "liberal.") There is a reason why you don't engage in political argument with conservatives, and it isn't because of our different "perceptions". No, it's because, in great part, there are few "liberal" positions which can be rationally supported while those of the "conservatives" CAN. And the REASON that so few of "liberal" positions can be rationally supported is BECAUSE of the liberals' almost religious belief that their PERCEPTION of reality supplants ACTUAL reality.
CosmicConservative
I wish that the national dialog would stop using the word "liberal" to describe the modern progressive ideology. It is a great disservice to the classical liberal philosophy to associate it with the platform and general beliefs of the modern progressive. I agree with Drax that the modern conservative is in many ways much closer to the "liberal" ideal, and that is clear when you see that libertarians who vote pragmatically are aligning themselves more and more with conservatives than with progressives. Even Libertarians are realizing that personal liberty and over-arching governmental bureaucracy are mutually exclusive concepts. It really isn't the "conservatives will have your grandparents eating dogfood" meme that I would point to as progressive irrationality, even though I did use that one above. I used that one because that was literally an accusation made against Ronald Reagan on the floor of the Senate. But I doubt most progressives "believe" that. However. What I see promoted by leading Democrats on a daily basis are the following even more ridiculous memes that ARE repeated with enough sincerity by progressives I have talked with that I have to conclude they are believed: 1. Conservatives are racist, sexist homophobes. 2. Conservatives will force women to become sex slaves of a new patriarchy. 3. Conservatives will turn the nation into a Christian state. 4. Conservatives will steal money from the poor to give to the rich. 5. Conservatives will revoke Social Security, Medicare, Food stamps and every other "safety net" and throw the poor, the old and minorities into the streets. I see these (and other similar insane things) said enough that I can't escape the conclusion that some, maybe most, progressives believe them to be true. And they are absolutely, as Drax would say, totally and in every conceivable manner... Insane. Yet they are believed and stated with conviction regularly. Such a thing is very close to pure, unadulterated evil. Yet progressives who don't believe it.... Don't demand that their leaders stop it. Which is just as bad. That's pretty much what I think of progressives. Well, besides that they have been dead wrong on virtually every critically important issue of the last forty years, from the Cold War to Welfare reform... But that's for another post.
Jack
Hi guys! I only commented on this thread because the title of the thread was "Your Debate Thoughts?" I decided that being probably the only liberal who occasionally comments here (never about politics), that I would give a liberal perspective, probably the only one on this blog. I also mention that I hesitate because I don't want to be "piled on". My perspective of the debate was that (paraphrased) "your guy won." But that wasn't quite good enough, was it? (I say "quite" because our host had a very polite response which included a Star Wars quote, to which I responded with another Star Wars quote and I thought that was the end of it.) But not for Drax. I had said his guy won but he had to let me know that Romney "demolished" Obama. And also had to let me know that he would handily do it in the next debates. His first sentence in his post disputed our memories of the Bush/Kerry debate but, for the record, in the last 16 presidential debates, the bump was about 1% for the assumed winner, except for the first Bush/Kerry debate; it was a shocking 2.26% bump for Kerry. You can look it up; I did and saw that I was right but didn't bother to post it at the time because I didn't care. And simply being right is really what all the political posturing boils down to, isn't it? But I ignored Drax's post because what difference does it make; he's not going to change my mind and I'm not going to change his. Then Dadman asked me a question. I had to answer him (in some way) because I like him and truly believe he's sincere and isn't setting me up for a kick to the crotch. But here's the problem: Though Dadman and CC will both treat me respectfully (which I always return), I know that this blog has the eyes of others with an opposite view who might be inclined for an incendiary conflict for which I have no stomach for on this blog. Nonetheless I made a post because I like Dadman and felt he deserved a response. The moment I hit send, I said to my gorgeous fiancee', "someone is going to accuse me of not responding claiming I can't argue my position." No kidding! That's what I said. And her response was, wait for it, wait for it... "Jack, you're over-thinking it. No one would be that petty." No kidding, that's what she said. And she was right when it came to CC and Dadman. Those guys gave me respectful answers. Dadman clearly understood the incendiary nature of it and CC understood the disconnect between people with different ideologies. So I wake up this morning with another response from Drax. He quotes me (which is actually me, in part, quoting CC) and says that the view that "Romney, blah, blah, blah... dogfood" is insane, not reasonable. At the root of that I don't disagree. But what about Obamageddon? I noticed that that was conveniently spun out of the equation. I also think that's insane, but guess what Drax, you don't, do you? And your friend, CC, is caught squarely in the crosshairs because in his very own post he drew a direct connection between someone who believes in Obamageddon (him, at times) and someone who believes in "Romney = dogfood for seniors." So, when all of the icing is cleared off the cake, and we view the statement in the raw, without spin, you called CC insane. I made the comparison of reasonableness because sometimes CC truly believes that re-electing Obama will lead to disaster of some sort and other times he shakes it off and sees the view as silly (which it is). People on the other side have the same panic and also shake it off. That is all I meant. But you took the partisan route and latched onto what I wrote without the full context spread out over several posts. But none of this matters to you. None of it. Then you say I don't argue because I can't support my positions. No, it's because "what's the point? I've argued plenty of times in other venues and in person (my preferred method). But there is one blogger in particular (who will remain nameless) that is run by a personal friend of mine and, recently, updated a post because he concluded I was right. The problem was he hadn't fact-checked his claims. I took the time to do it and called him on it. But he is a friend of mine for 30 years now, so I can argue vehemently with him if I want. I don't do that with strangers online because I consider it impolite. I could also go on and state how Republicans are the current party playing politics right now with the country hanging in the balance. Everyone knows Mitch Occonnell said their primary goal was to make Obama a one-term president and they have commenced to block everything he's tried to do. That is not being statesmen; that is playing to one's ideology. Take the debt ceiling crisis and the contribution it had to the downgraded US credit. Raising the ceiling is routine, but it was completely politicized by the Republicans. To prove this, I could go on and do what you would do; what most people would do actually. And that is put out quotes or info acquired from blogs, online and print news, and cable news. Or I could relate a personal experience. You see, I am "boots on the ground" in our global community. I don't "see" what's going on through outside sources. I experience it. Anyway, right around the time of the debt ceiling crisis, I was poised to receive another enormous royalty check consolidated from about 30 countries from my last feature film, which is still airing on cable overseas. I was very concerned, because if the US credit rating was downgraded, it would effect the exchange rates potentially costing me hundreds of thousands of dollars. I even flew to DC for a couple days to talk to people. I want to keep doing what I'm doing so I was worried about the royalty distribution to myself and my American investors (not sure at the time how it would effect my foreign investors; turned out it depended on the country). So I went to DC and I wasn't alone. There were a lot of people who traveled there who were very concerned. And everybody, across the entire political spectrum, knew exactly what was going on: the Republicans were playing politics with the American investor. It was essentially Russian Roulette, except they were clicking the gun at our collective heads, not theirs. Anyway, we all know what happened. And I lost hundreds of thousands of dollars in the process. The only difference between what I know and what you know is that my info is unfiltered and delivered to my face. I could tell you that every millionaire I know (and I know dozens), Republican, Democrat, or independent, without hesitation will tell me that they've financially done better when the Democrats are in power. I could site theories as to why, but what's the point. I say "theories" because everyone (who moves in the circles I move in) understands there is no bygone conclusion of what the result of any political action will be. Even looking at the past for answers is somewhat murky because there are so many variables (some known, some unknown) that are constantly changing as to make it hard to nail down exactly the outcome of any action. That's why reasonable people can disagree. You also said that liberals don't perceive reality at all. Hmmm... I'm a liberal... so I'll assume that that comment was aimed at me. An attack on a total stranger. From an anonymous poster. I'm not anonymous, you can look me up. The question here is: If I was disconnected from reality, where would that put me? In a mental institution? Homeless? Living on the dole in some way? Obviously, if my take on reality is completely wrong, then I can't possibly live a normal life, right? Or better than a normal life, right? Or couldn't possibly be living, dare I say... the American Dream. Right? I only have one brain. Not two. Just one. Like you, Drax. And everyone else in the world. All my life-decisions have to come from my one and only brain. My out-of-touc-with-reality, insane, liberal brain. I came from a lower middle-class family in St. Louis. I started working at 16, was on my own by 19. Didn't go to college but started several businesses. Along the way, I experienced firsthand that the only assistance a small business really gets are from liberal policies. In my experience, conservative policies are geared toward helping big corporations. I'm not talking about handouts, I'm talking about regulations and just, in generally, creating a more business friendly experience. Is this experience anecdotal? Yes. But as the years rolled on, I met others with the same experience. Over and over and over again. I could babble on for days but what's the point. Sentences from what I've written will be cherry-picked and and dissected and taken out of context. It's already happened. But here's what I will do. I'll tell you about my American Dream. For my entire life, I've wanted to be a screenwriter and film director. So, in my mid-40s, using my liberal (out of touch with reality and insane) brain, I analyzed what elements needed to be in a screenplay to attract a Hollywood cast, the minimal budget I needed to pull it off, the type of investor I needed to approach, and how to approach them. And do it all remotely, from 1800 miles away from a business community where I had zero contacts. On a side note: Politics comes into play when raising money. You have to approach a wealthy conservative differently than you have to approach a wealthy liberal. And there are more wealthy liberals than conservatives. Period. And the liberals are more likely to take a risk. Period. I'm living proof of that myself. And finally, I calculated the odds of selling a low-budget film (still multimillion dollar) to a major studio. I ended up with approximately 1 in 500. Which is not bad relative to winning the lottery. Of course, buying a lottery ticket is less difficult than writing/directing/producing a feature-length motion picture. Every conservative I knew thought that what I was attempting to do was deluded and crazy. None of the liberals I knew, thought that? Why is that? End result: Feature film completed and sold to 20th Century Fox and NBC/Universal. You can look all this up on IMDb. The success exceeded my expectations by a wide margin. For my next miracle to try with my liberal (out of touch with reality) brain was to repeat with a bigger film and get it into a major film festival. End result: Feature film completed and screened at Cannes this past May. I am a liberal and living the American Dream. The world is my playground. From my perch I see that liberal polices have a, generally, better effect on the world. I don't come to this from blogs and cable news; this is what I see from "boots on the ground" living. Not too bad for an out-of-touch-with-reality, insane liberal. I conclude my perception on reality has a direct connection to the outcome of my life. You gentlemen can interpret my life and experiences as you will. I now take my leave. I hope you all have great, successful lives. CC, you are a helluva writer. I have found your posts, on any topic, well-written and engaging regardless of whether or not I agree with your politics. You should finish that damned book of yours and get it out there. Take a risk, man! I think you might be pleasantly surprised. :-)
CosmicConservative
Jack, I hope you don't leave for good. I understand your reaction though. This is one reason why it is so hard to discuss politics. As I tried to say in my post, my biggest bewilderment in the "liberal" worldview is how it can be possible that conservatives are hated so violently and how accusations of racism, sexism, homophobism, stupidity, desire to exploit the poor, etc... how can anyone think that other people could be that heartless, cruel and stupid? That's what I don't get. I do think that there really is a sense among conservatives that "liberals" live in a sort of unicorn and rainbow fantasy world, which is definitely condescending and simplistic, but it's a sort of general befuddlement about how the "liberal" mind works. From my perspective though, what I see on the other side is that "liberals" in general accuse conservatives of being cruel, evil and vicious monsters. That's what I don't get, and what frustrates me terribly. I know that I fall into the same general ideological trap of thinking that my side is "right" and the other side is "wrong". I fight it, but I don't always succeed. But even when I fail, I might question a "liberal's" hold on reality, but I don't question their morality or call them evil monsters.
Dadman
Thanks for sharing your story, Jack. Very compelling.
CosmicConservative
Jack, one other comment. I don't really have time right now to respond to your well thought out and presented comment, but I find it very compelling. I particularly think that your observations about risk-taking are worth digging into. I think most people would agree that conservatives (being conservative) tend to take fewer risks than progressives. But the thing about risks is that sometimes they pan out, and sometimes they don't. That's why they are risks. And the risk/benefit analysis is a very difficult thing to do for a lot of reasons, not the least of which involves specific life situations (such as having a special needs family member) and willingness to "risk" those things. In the end "taking a risk" is all well and good when it works out. When it fails, well... then it fails. One reason there are so many "success stories" about there from people who took a risk and succeeded is because they succeeded. People who take risks and fail tend not to advertise that fact, and in some cases, may no longer be in a position to do so anyway, having lost all they have. So it's a difficult thing to resolve.
Drax
Jack: One at a time. The comparison between "Obamageddon" and "Republicans want to make granny eat catfood." (Or throw her onto the streets. Or throw her down the stairs. Or wants autistic kids not to have health care. Or want those who can't fend for themselves to sleep under trees. Pick your particular poison as to what Democratic or Democratic ally says in CAMPAIGN ADS) is simple. Believing any of those things about Republicans is insane. As you admit. But, looking at what Obama has done these past 3+ years, how he has done it, and viewing the entire arc of his life - coming to the conclusion that, if he gets re-elected, then he will continue to "transform" the U.S. until it is no longer a world power - is a conclusion which can be rationally supported. Thus, NOT "insane." As to your allegation that it is the Republicans "playing politics" and "putting a gun to the heads" of the U.S. citizens - well, that's just an allegation, isn't it? When the President cannot get a single vote for two of his budgets, who's "playing politics?" When he can't get "cap and trade" through, then attempts (and partially succeeds) to do an end run around Congress via regulations, who is "playing politics?" When the President "negotiates" with the Republicans by ending the "negotiation" by telling them "I won," who is playing politics? If the President proposes something which is not only against the fundamental principles of Republicans and won't budge in his position, then who is "playing politics" when Republicans don't simply roll over and give him what he wants? In order for your story to have any weight in this argument, (I'm seriously sorry for your financial loss while, at the same time, happy for your achievement in getting your feature shot. you will have to tell me three things: 1) What proposal, exactly, was on the table (advanced by the Democrats or the President) which would have prevented your loss, 2) How the Republicans prevented it from happening, and 3) How the actions of the Republicans was "playing politics" rather than acting in accordance with their principles. Absent your being able to produce these three things, then your assertion that it is the Republicans "playing politics" which is causing this "gridlock" is no more than puffing air. As to whether or not I was targeting YOU in my jab at the sanity of "liberals," you'll have to read my post a bit more carefully. First, I try to make sure that I use the quotes when I say "liberals." Second, I term MYSELF a liberal - albeit a classical one. Third, I make sure that defining what is a "liberal" is problematic. (As CC noted, many of those who CALL themselves "liberal" are, in fact, progressives. I will assert that many of those who call themselves "liberal" are, indeed, progressive, socialist, communist, and/or facist.) I haven't a CLUE as to what your ACTUAL leanings are. For all I know, you are only a tad more left leaning than am I but have a clear hold on reality. To be clear. There is a REASON why this country (and most of the western world) has the "conservative"/"liberal" divide. And, it's because both sides have, in great part, reasonable and rational reasons for believing as they do - and can support their decision to be one or the other in a non-insane manner. That isn't who I'm talking about. I'm talking about the progressives who believe in a world which simply doesn't exist and, no matter what facts you present to them, continue to see a reality which does not exist. Again, to be clear. For five decades, conservatives have been warning of what would happen - every step of the way - when so-called "liberal" policies were enacted. In almost every case, conservative predictions have proven to be true, whether you talk about deficit spending, welfare, social security, medicare, affirmative action, interpreting a "living Constitution," etc. etc. etc. Yet, "liberals" continue to say that we not only need to continue with these failed (and destructive) policies, but we need to EXPAND them. Because these issues aren't a matter of "politics" with them (deciding who gets what and when as someone said) but an article of FAITH. When you say that "liberal policies" make the world a better place, you really have to define your terms and support your conclusions. If you mean how it's going over in Europe, then I gotta say that I'm pretty sure that I have to disagree with you. If you're simply comparing "liberal" to the non-western world, then, I'd have to agree in great part. (But, we're not comparing ourselves to them, are we? We're comparing ourselves to ... ourselves.) And, further, you have to ask yourself whether or not these other western countries could have implemented these "liberal policies" had not they had the defensive umbrella of the United States sheltering them. Could they have afforded what they were doing had they been responsible for their own defense? (Or, more likely, would they have simply run out of other peoples' money at a much earlier time?) So, no. I'm not calling YOU "insane." You sound quite sane. (And, frankly, what I meant is that holding the IDEA is insane. Many of us hold insane ideas - ideas which don't reflect reality. But, I HOPE that I'm "sane" enough that, when presented with facts and the reasonable and rational conclusions which can be drawn from those facts, that I can discard such "insane" ideas in favor of something which more accurately reflects reality. Heh. Good post.
Drax
Oh, the Kerry/Bush thing. Maybe it was a little more one-sided than I remembered (but I thought that Palin won her debate as well - as did a slim majority polled immediately after the debate. It wasn't until the MSM dive-bombed her 24/7 for days that things changed.) But, it wasn't anything like this debacle. We're talking 2-1 victory margin where 1/2 of the Democrats say that Romney won. Even the MSNBC talking heads were pulling their hair out. There simply hasn't been anything like this before. (Some are saying that the Reagan/Carter debate was as bad. On substance, it was. But, Carter, at least, fought hard and knew his material.) But, over the next week, the MSM will continue to push the meme that the only reason that Romney "won" is that he cheated by lying. And, anyway, the margin wasn't nearly as big as it seemed. After all, Obama make a lot of good points. He won on the Medicare segment, didn't he? Etc. Etc. Watch over the weeks as the so-called "objective" MSM "reporters" carry his water. It'll happen. But, I echo CC's remarks. Please don't go away! Because, unlike you, I DO believe that if you talk about something, the possibility of changing one's mind always exists. If all one does in talk in an echo chamber, the results are entirely predictable.