Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The truth about trolls

By CosmicConservative
Not online trolls, real trolls. Neanderthals survived much longer than was previously thought. I have been convinced that neanderthal bands were the source of troll and troglodyte myths ever since I first realized that neanderthal and homo sapiens lived at the same time. This just provides further ammo. Since I believe that oral tradition is more accurate than most people believe, I think that many of the stories of troll behavior are pretty accurately describing neanderthal behavior. I love how I find little interesting tidbits in these kinds of stories:
The Neanderthals probably roamed a large area and used the cave periodically as a place to cook, eat and sleep, he said. The cave has yielded butchered bones of such animals as wild goat and deer, and remains of mussels and shellfish. At the time of the Neanderthals, the Mediterranean Sea was about three miles away; rising sea level has since brought the water to within a few dozen yards.
Wait! Sea Levels have not moved 3 miles in modern times! Global Warming in the past two decades certainly has not done this! Are these scientists suggesting that sea levels have risen enough to inundate 3 miles of coast along Spain without George Bush being responsible? No way, this has to be some mistake. ;)

Comments (9)

James
I recently came to the same conclusion myself.
Daniel
I also came to the conclusion about trolls and neanderthals, and I really like your idea of looking into old troll-stories to learn more about neanderthals. Do you have any more sources on that? The reason the sea levels have risen is because the ice caps held an enormous amount of frozen water at that time due to the ice age. But maybe you already had that figured out. ;-)
CosmicConservative
Actually ice melting from the "ice caps" don't actually increase sea level. Only ice melting on land and flowing to the ocean causes rises in sea level. The other thing that causes sea levels to rise is the natural expansion of the water itself as the temperature increases. One of the things that drives me nuts is when brain-washed eco-nuts talk about the Arctic ice caps melting and flooding the world. If you melted every scrap of ice floating in the Arctic ocean, it would not raise sea levels a millimeter because the ice is already displacing exactly the same amount of water by floating on top of the water. This is why knowledgeable climatologists worry about the Greenland glaciers melting. That would cause water to flow to the sea and potentially raise the ocean levels. But I think even that is seriously overestimated because glaciers on land tend to melt and leave pools of water behind on land, like the Great Lakes, for example...
Jacek Piskozub
>>Actually ice melting from the “ice caps” don’t actually increase sea level. Only ice melting on land and flowing to the ocean causes rises in sea level.
Jacek Piskozub
Part of my comment has been eaten by the system. I repost it below. That's correct but you forgot that the "ice caps" (more correctly called ice-sheets) were on land, over modern Scandinavia, Canada and northern part of the United States. There was enough ice in the ice sheets some 20 thousands years ago to make the sea level about 120 meters lower than at present. The three miles mentioned above was of course the *horizontal* displacement of the shoreline.
Neandertroll
Neanderthals were an offshoot of Homo Erectus who were early humans who populated Europe and parts of Asia and were well adapted to Ice Age conditions though it needs to be noted that they survived several interglacial periods like the conditions we are living in today. I wont go into the Milankovic theory but ice ages in the present few millions of years last about 90,000-100,000 years and interglacials last about 10,000-15,000 years (we are about 11,700 years through our present interglacial so watch out for icebergs in your backyard pool). However Neaderthals were an offshoot of an earlier human species as were Homo Sapiens. They were probably genetically a separate species and therefore unable to interbreed, though there are suggestions that there were mule progenies, children born without the capacity to breed themselves. Neaderthals were as smart as us but in a different way. Its suggested that the mutation that allowed us to communicate effectively verbally appeared about 2-300000 years ago so its questionable if the Neanderthal had this gene (separation between us and Neanderthal was about 3-400000 years). Doesnt mean though that they couldnt speak in some manner and they probably used a much more effective verbal/mannerism communication. Regrettably the Neanderthal seem not to have lived in large communities because of their environment which allowed survival of only a small number per square kilometre/mile (bit like Australian Aborigines in desert environment). Therefore interaction and therefore quick development of innovations was retarded despite their obvious intellect. There was little specialisation like you have in Homo Sapiens communities. But Neaderthals were very smart and well adapted to their environment. They were also very strong (the women would embarrass big Arnie in a wrestling match). They were about 5-5 1/2 feet tall slightly shorter than us, barrel chested, heavy forehead, no chin, long armed and short legged, big nosed and probably red headed or blond and possibly blue or green eyed. Their head sloped back but was longer and their brain capacity was larger than ours, but their brains were larger in different areas from ours. Their behaviour matches Trolls almost perfectly as described in northern myths and its not surprising that the myths came from there suggesting an almost genetic memory of at least 20,000-30,000 years because at present that's supposedly the last time they lived (Spain about 25,000 years ago is the last fossil age). We probably outcompeted them because of our socialisation advantage and better tools (like American Indians and Australian Aboriginies facing Europeans). Maybe it was disease or maybe genocide. Very sad we have lost these Human cousins who could have taught us much - and perhaps they did. And for those challenging the sea level issue. the sea level increased about 400 feet world wide after the last ice age ( depending upon the continental rebounding effect) between 14,500 and 8,500 years ago. The last rapid increase of about 20-30 feet was probably the source of the Noah myths world wide. What would the world be like if Neaderthals still lived?
Ramirez
I recently came to the same conclusion. In fact it is interesting to see that Neanderthal reconstructions have come ever closer to trolls, particularly this one: http://www.donsmaps.com/images12/neanderthalmodelIMG_1499.jpg Neanderthal reconstructions have suffered much from the idea that everything more primitive than us in human evolution should look more like an ape. In fact, considering the time between the divide between humans and other great apes and humans and Neanderthals, Neanderthals probably looked just as much/little like apes as we do, yet different.
Andy
Heh! Talk about late to the party? :) Interesting, though...