NFL thoughts, Week 3
By CosmicConservativeI try not to be hyper-reactive to faddish things. When the NFL season started with replacement officials I was not overly concerned. After all officiating a football game is not brain surgery or quantum physics. Surely a bunch of intelligent guys (and gal) who have been officiating at college for decades could get up to speed on the NFL version of the rules and run a football game reasonably well. I mean after all it's not like the "real" officials don't screw up plays on a regular basis. I would say that I may never have seen an NFL game where I didn't think at least one critical call was blown by an official. So my expectation was that there would be some rough edges to the officiating during pre-season but that by the time the regular season started things would be reasonably well in hand.
I watched parts of three football games this weekend. I watched parts of the Denver/Houston game, the Green Bay/Seattle game and the New England/Baltimore game.
In each of those games I felt the poor officiating had a direct and negative impact on the outcome of the game. Of course the play everyone is talking about today is the Seattle "Hail Mary" pass that appeared to be intercepted but was ruled a Seattle touchdown. But that play only happened because of half a dozen previously blown plays where the officials routinely screwed up pass interference, holding, illegal contact or even crazy stuff like timeout management.
I am now firmly in the camp of "get the real officials back before the game's integrity is blown".
What happens now if the Green Bay Packers miss the playoffs by one game? Or the Patriots, who were screwed just as thoroughly? I actually think the Broncos benefited from most of the blown calls in their game and lost anyway, so that game at least shouldn't be an issue. But the other two games, in my opinion, called correctly would have had the opposite result and Green Bay and New England would now be 2-1, not 1-2.
Comments (4)