Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

NFL thoughts, Week 3

By CosmicConservative
I try not to be hyper-reactive to faddish things. When the NFL season started with replacement officials I was not overly concerned. After all officiating a football game is not brain surgery or quantum physics. Surely a bunch of intelligent guys (and gal) who have been officiating at college for decades could get up to speed on the NFL version of the rules and run a football game reasonably well. I mean after all it's not like the "real" officials don't screw up plays on a regular basis. I would say that I may never have seen an NFL game where I didn't think at least one critical call was blown by an official. So my expectation was that there would be some rough edges to the officiating during pre-season but that by the time the regular season started things would be reasonably well in hand. I watched parts of three football games this weekend. I watched parts of the Denver/Houston game, the Green Bay/Seattle game and the New England/Baltimore game. In each of those games I felt the poor officiating had a direct and negative impact on the outcome of the game. Of course the play everyone is talking about today is the Seattle "Hail Mary" pass that appeared to be intercepted but was ruled a Seattle touchdown. But that play only happened because of half a dozen previously blown plays where the officials routinely screwed up pass interference, holding, illegal contact or even crazy stuff like timeout management. I am now firmly in the camp of "get the real officials back before the game's integrity is blown". What happens now if the Green Bay Packers miss the playoffs by one game? Or the Patriots, who were screwed just as thoroughly? I actually think the Broncos benefited from most of the blown calls in their game and lost anyway, so that game at least shouldn't be an issue. But the other two games, in my opinion, called correctly would have had the opposite result and Green Bay and New England would now be 2-1, not 1-2.

Comments (4)

CosmicConservative
So, FWIW I went to the ESPN stats pages and looked at how Denver, as a team, is doing right now compared to last year. As you might expect, they have improved in the passing area, moving from #31 in 2011 to #14. But that's all so far, is #14, which is pretty much the definition of mediocre. On the other hand they have gone from #1 in rushing to #23 in rushing. Their 2011 rushing yards per game (including the first five games where they sucked at everything) was 164 yds/game. So far this year they are at 90 yds/game. That's a drop of 45%. One of the things I heard repeatedly from the "experts" during the offseason was how much of a powerhouse they were going to be in 2012 because they had the top rushing attack in the league and to that they were adding the best QB of all time. That could only mean they would be supremely balanced and unstoppable. I called in to a few shows and suggested that perhaps Denver's rushing success last year could be due to the presence of one Tim Tebow (who rushed for almost 60 yards per game himself, and whose mere presence opened up the line for other Denver running backs) but I was roundly ridiculed as a Tebow fanboi (which may be true, but it's not relevant to the statistical realities). I was told that Denver's rushing game was due to the resurgence of Willis McGahee who was going to be even more dominant in 2012 with a true passing threat causing opposing teams to drop more into coverage. McGahee is averaging 70 yards per game, which is very close to what Tim Tebow averaged in 2011 as a QB. One thing I am not hearing on the talk shows this year is any discussion of how the Broncos running game has fallen apart, or why. Instead it's all about how the defense isn't playing well or the receivers are dropping the perfectly placed balls of Peyton Manning. It's a long season but so far it is playing out just about as I expected it to.
Drax
Couple of things: First, 70 yards a game ain't bad. Over 1000 yards which, for most, is a good season. But, there ain't much beyond his yardage. Second, the "scabs." I, too, want professional refs again. But... They are paid 8k per week for a part time job and want a raise. ??? They get a generous pension which the owners no longer want to support for part time employees. They DON'T want to add refs so that they have replacement refs. They DON'T want to have their performance evaluated and the "bad" refs "benched" or otherwise punished for poor performance. They DON'T want to become full time and be subject to physical requirements so that the car salesmen and other middle-aged fatties can still collect a paycheck without being in good enough shape to keep up with world class athletes. If the owners give in because the replacement refs aren't doing a good job, then the regular refs have the owners by the BALLS for the rest of eternity. It takes two to tango. The owners have a proposal on the table - one they think is fair. One which even the wailing talking heads ACKNOWLEDGE would make the game better by having better trained, better conditioned, and more answerable people refereeing the games. But, if the owners don't let the bad PR and the wailing of the talking heads force them into a decision which is bad from a business perspective and bad for football (in the long run) then we will either end up with a new group of better trained refs (the current scabs) or a group of better trained professional cadre of refs who are actually answerable to the OWNERS of the game for their PERFORMANCE in those games. But, I wish they'd get it settled soon.
Drax
And, it really ticks me off that these professional "journalists" who opine neither (for the most part) acknowledge that the Commissioner doesn't have the unilateral power to fix the problem and curse him (literally) for letting the current situation continue NOR do they acknowledge (for the most part) that the owners actually are trying to make the game better and are being RESISTED by a union which is attempting a money/power grab. And...if the money that the owners will have to spend for the pensions and raises were to come out of the pockets of the PLAYERS, then I bet they would be singing a different tune...
CosmicConservative
70 yards per game indeed "ain't bad." But it ain't good either. It would have put McGahee in 18th place among active running backs last season, and has him in fifteenth place among active backs this season. Which puts him right at about "average" for modern NFL running backs. That might be OK if Denver had anyone else running the ball to carry some slack, but they don't. McGahee pretty much is the Denver running attack. Which is why Denver has dropped from #1 to #23. And if things don't change, I suspect that will drop even further. The brain trust in Dove Valley has reportedly decided that what Denver needs is more Peyton Manning and less pounding the football. Which may be right. So far this year the Broncos are a lackluster team until they give Peyton the ball and tell him to try to win it. That sounds familiar, except that they are giving the ball to Peyton much earlier than they were giving it to Tebow last year. My guess is that they will come out in no-huddle virtually the entire game against Oakland. And while McGahee will get his share of carries, the focus is going to be on Manning's gilded right arm. As far as the owners vs the refs is concerned, I guess I'm sliding back to my previous "give the replacements time and they'll be just as good as the 'real' refs" position I started the season at. I let myself get caught up in the hype today after all.