Some thoughts on Peyton Manning so far
By CosmicConservativeI made no secret of my disappointment in the Denver Broncos decision to kick Tim Tebow to the curb after Tebow virtually single-handedly rescued their season in 2011, ultimately winning the first playoff game he started and posting an 8-5 record overall for the year.
But what's done is done and since I live in the Denver area and I do like to see my local teams win, I can't help but root for the Broncos in spite of my absolute disgust at the team's front office, especially John Elway. Plus I just always liked Peyton Manning, even though I think he is somewhat overrated from an NFL history perspective. The game is just so much different today that calling him the "best ever" due to his yardage and touchdowns just isn't a compelling argument to me. I can't help but wonder what sort of gaudy numbers Dan Fouts would have had if he had played QB under the current pass-happy rules in the NFL. Or even Dan Marino, whose career sort of spanned the period where the game changed into a pass-centric approach.
But when Peyton Manning was brought to the Broncos, even forgetting the whole Tim Tebow angle, I had several concerns. And while two games isn't really enough to make a final determination on Peyton Manning's QB abilties, there is enough data there that it is worth looking at. I can guarantee you that opposing defensive coordinators are looking at it.
So, these were my concerns:
1. Peyton Manning played in a dome for all of his home games and many of his away games. His numbers have always been better in domes than in open stadiums. Not only is Denver's stadium an open air stadium, Denver's weather is among the most fickle in the NFL.
2. There really is something to the "mile high" thing. And as athletes get older, dealing with the lower oxygen content truly does get harder. This affects stamina and even young athletes in Denver tend to wear down faster than athletes who play all year at sea level.
3. While the surgery Manning had done may well have "left his neck stronger than before" as all the pundits and experts like to say, there is no way that surgery of this sort did not have some impact on Peyton's body. What that impact is may be difficult to exactly determine but there is no way that sort of surgery did not affect his range of motion, his flexibility and/or his throwing mechanics.
4. While the aftermath of his condition and surgery may not have had a major impact on his bones or muscles, there is no doubt that it had some impact on his nerves. One common aftereffect of surgery that impacts major nerves is that those nerves frequently lose some of their effectiveness, which manifests itself most commonly as less efficiency in triggering muscle activity. The result of that is usually that even though the actual muscle may well be as strong or stronger after therapy, the actual process of triggering an action using that muscle may not engage as many muscle fibers, and the result is a weaker response.
5. The guy is 36 years old and missed more than a year of play time.
6. Even the best athletes tend to compensate for injuries unconsciously whether they want to or not.
So, my fear was that some or all of the above things would mean that Peyton Manning would not be the same guy behind center, no matter how much the Broncos brass wished that not to be true.
So... what are the numbers showing us so far this year?
1. Peyton's ball velocity is roughly 5-10% slower than it was before surgery on the same sorts of throws.
2. Peyton's timing is not as sharp as it was before the surgery.
3. Peyton's effectiveness on deep throws is significantly diminished in comparison to his pre-surgery days.
Now does that mean Peyton is no longer an elite QB? I dunno. If Peyton can adjust to his throws being slightly less strong than they used to be so that he refines his timing, then timing patterns probably will not be affected. But I am really concerned about the deep balls. All three of Peyton's interceptions on Monday were on deep balls, and anyone who doesn't admit that those balls seemed to hang in the air just a tad too long is probably just not being honest. While it is true that arm strength is overrated in general for an NFL quarterback, the one area where arm strength really is important is in throws of 30 yards or more. The average "deep threat" throw in the NFL is about 35 yards in the air between the QB and the receiver. Most NFL QBs throw the ball around fifty miles an hour (Peyton was clocked at 46 mph on one such throw). That means the average QB puts the ball in the air for about 1.5 seconds. If Peyton has lost 5-10% of his throwing speed, that means his balls are staying in the air on those throws a bit more than a tenth of a second longer.
That doesn't sound like much, but it's enough time for an average DB to make up an additional yard or so on coverage.
Think about that. If Peyton's mind is still thinking he's throwing that ball 50mph when his body is really throwing at 45mph, then the DB has one yard more coverage than Peyton's mind thinks he does.
That one yard is more than enough to be the difference between a completion and an interception.
There are reports in the Denver sports press today that the Broncos were prepping Brock Osweiler, Peyton's backup, to go in and throw a hail mary pass if needed.
What does that say about the Broncos own evaluation of Peyton's arm strength? Do you think that the Patriots would put in Brady's backup in that situation?
I don't think so.
It is concerning.
Comments (14)