Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Metaphysics & Spirituality

On Cloning and Artificial Intelligence

By CosmicConservative
I have been reading Ray Kurzweil's book "The Singularity is Near" and it has gotten me thinking more about the future than I normally do, and I normally do that quite a bit. One of the things that it is making me think about is the difference in public acceptance of cloning and of artificial intelligence research. Cloning is generally viewed with deep suspicion, and in fact laws have been drawn up to outlaw any cloning research based on the premise that it is morally wrong to mess around with the fundamental properties of human life. Artificial Intelligence is generally viewed with puzzlement or cynicism, in fact many deeply religious people consider the research to be a fool's errand since they view human intelligence as the sole province of divine intervention. But it is probably true that Artificial Intelligence research is nearly as far down the road to practical reality as cloning is. In fact an artificial intelligence comparable to a human brain is now considered to be likely to be created within a decade or two, probably closer to a single decade. There are many roads on the map to get to a working AI system, but many of them essentially are reverse engineering the human brain and applying the patterns and techniques used by the brain to create electronic versions of the brain. In essence this is "cloning" the human brain's information processing capabilities. I haven't voiced an opinion on cloning here because I am conflicted on the subject, but up until now I have been highly supportive of AI research. I'm now wondering if these are fundamentally inconsistent positions. It might be helpful to describe "cloning" as mass producing the hardware of the human body, while "AI" is mass producing the software of the human mind. I think that history has taught us that the human mind is the more important of those two systems. So if I have some fundamental issue with recreating human life in a lab, then logic compels me to say that I should be more opposed to AI research than to cloning. Or at least equally. But I can't do it. I still find myself fully supportive of AI research. And if anything, that is making me rethink my position on cellular cloning.

Intelligent Design

By CosmicConservative
Isn't the word "intelligent" redundant? This is interesting to me because this is sort of the reverse of "Scientific Creationism" which is oxymoronic to me. When I see issues framed in this way it smacks of Focus Groups and Madison Avenue to me. It feels like the word "intelligent" is only put into the mix to avoid saying "divine," in an attempt to circumvent the supposed "wall of separation between church and state." Of course there can be no doubt that "intelligent design" is a fact. It happens all the time. Your pet dog is an example of the course of evolution being driven by an "outside purposeful force". In that case the "outside purposeful force" is man, of course. Should "intelligent design" be taught in public schools? If it is taught in a manner that respects the actual facts of the issue, then certainly it should be. But if it is taught in a manner that presents religious belief as "fact" then it should not be. In other words, it should be perfectly acceptable to point out that domestication of plants and animals over the past hundreds of thousands of years is a sterling example of an intelligent purpose driving evolution in a preferred direction, and achieving demonstrable results. It would be perfectly acceptable to me to extend that by speculating whether or not the process we can see happening right in front of our noses, is happening at larger (or smaller) scales. But that's precisely when the subject should leave the science classroom and go to the philosophy classroom.