In the context of the discussion around the "right" of Iran to have nuclear power, the question of the actual existence of human rights has come up. Since that is a more abstract and fundamental question than the narrow context of nuclear power (and weapons), I decided to create a new post to discuss whether there is any such thing as "human rights."
The concept of "human rights" is not a new thing. In most history books of Western Civilization, the first "official" mention of such rights is usually traced back to the "
Magna Carta" in 1215. This document proclaimed that English subjects of the King had certain "rights" that the King himself could not LEGALLY override, primarily including the rights of habeus corpus and due process.
The Magna Carta was a powerful influence on the early settlers of North America and inspired, among other documents, the Mayflower Compact, the Declaration of Independence and the United States Constitution.
It was the Declaration of Independence itself which first and most forcefully proclaimed the "self-evidence" of "natural human rights." The "natural" in those quotations is important because Jefferson and most of the other founders of our country believed in "natural" rights as being rights granted by an all-powerful being (not necessarily the same thing as the modern concept of "God" by the way) to ALL men.
The actual wording in the Declaration of Independence is: "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness." When the first completed draft of the US Constitution had no reference to Human Rights, Thomas Jefferson refused to support its adoption until the first ten amendments, now known as the "Bill of Rights" was added to the Constitution.
Jefferson and Madison in particular wrote at length about the existence and providential source of natural human rights. It was this expression of natural human rights that led to the rejection of the feudal system of Kings, barons, dukes and lords. In fact it was the very expression of these "natural human rights" that led Jefferson and most other founders of this nation to proclaim independence from England.
But all that means is that our founding fathers BELIEVED in human rights, it doesn't mean that there actually are any such rights outside of the imaginations of certain enlightened and libertarian minds. It is just as questionable whether any two people would agree upon the deliniation of any discrete and complete set of such rights.
So it is a fair question to ask whether there is any existential reality behind "natural human rights" or if the concept is purely the product of human political and philosophical debate.
Similar questions could be asked about the existential nature of such concepts as "justice" or "honor" or "liberty" or "freedom" or any other abstract concept which governs (or should govern) human affairs.
I personally take the position that such concepts may be abstract, but they still
exist. In some respects most, if not all, such rights can be traced back to the philosophical concept of "reciprocity" which is most commonly described as the "Golden Rule" or "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you." In my mind this concept is so universally acknowledged in the world's religions and
enlightened government systems that it is unlikely to have spontaneously arisen simply out of random chance.
Reciprocity IS the fundamental expression of natural rights. It is the wellspring of the concepts of justice, fairness, honor and many, many other things that people think of as abstract concepts. But it is not an abstract concept in itself. In fact it is unlikely, in my mind, that ANY sufficiently advanced culture would not eventually recognize and adopt reciprocity as a core underpinning of any social system governing the actions of a group of individuals.
In that sense I believe that human rights are "real" not simply abstract statements that have no basis in reality. To me reciprocity is as fundamental to the universe as gravity or electro-magnetism. It is not merely a concept, it is something which provides a fundamental force in societies towards fairness and justice. Yes, there are no doubt many societies which move against this tide because there are OTHER forces, such as selfishness, which oppose reciprocity. In fact the interplay of selfishness and reciprocity drive much of a society's fundamental conflict. Both are real. Both are forces which affect the real world and the real universe.