Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Hobbies

Yet another WoW update

By CosmicConservative
Just to keep you all up to speed in with my virtual adventuring... Things have slowed down rather dramatically in the past week or so. Where I had been moving multiple levels upward each day, now I'm more or less ignoring level entirely as I have focused on learning the more complex aspects of the game, particulary the optimization of combat options. But I have also spent a good chunk of my online time working on making my characters profitable meaning that they make more virtual money than they spend. I'm not quite there yet. I thought I was but then I got my behind whupped pretty good in a player vs. player duel that I should have won, and it became clear that my generally middle-of-the-road equipment was simply not going to cut it in the "Twinked" world of player vs. player combat. So I went to the auction house and spent virtually all of my fortune on new weapons and armor. I had not been doing that up until now because I didn't want to blow 100 gold pieces on items that would only be good for a couple of levels. But, as they say in business and sports, don't expect to compete if you don't have the right tools. The upgrade has significantly improved my day-to-day combat, but I haven't gone back to PvP since then, so I don't know if it will have that much of an impact where it really counts. Regardless, I'm more or less broke again now. I have been advancing a second character (a gnome mage) up the levels and managed to get that character up to level 17 so far. I created that character specifically to allow me to work on the same level as the Cosmic Daughter or other characters from other players that I know. Last night I used that character to take the CD on a wide-ranging tour of the world of WoW, helping her to complete her druid quest which allows her to take a new form (I think the form is "Sea Lion"). Having said that, I do want to take a minute to talk about the actual "World" of "World of Warcraft." I think I'm usually a fairly harsh critic of game design, having designed and written some of my own. And there is plenty to find fault with for sure. Sometimes I think my natural career would have been in computer or board game design, but I never found a way to make enough money at it. The bottom line is that I am pretty quick to spot issues in a game that I think should easily have gone better. I was a particularly harsh critic of EQ in that way, as much as I enjoyed the game otherwise. Having said all that, and understanding that the graphics in WoW are a few generations behind modern heavy-client game programs (like Oblivion, for example) I still have to say that the game designers in WoW did a remarkable job of making the world an engaging one. They really managed to convey a sense of epic proportions that can sometimes nearly take your breath away. For example, the city of Ironforge is almost certainly my favorite part of WoW right now, from a pure game-design perspective. Whoever designed the "dwarven" parts of WoW, whether it is Ironforge itself (the capital of the Dwarven race) or if it is the dwarven tunnels that take you between the different areas of the game, the result simply oozes dwarvishness. Even something as simple as a dwarven tunnel is done on an epic scale, with precision and style. Dwarves in WoW build BIG. In fact the obvious conclusion to draw after visiting typical dwarven architecture is that the dwarves over-compensate for their shortness of stature with epic architecture that can only be described as "grand." This feeling of gargantuan scale is best found in Ironforge, where the walls loom overhead like great cliffs of precisely laid and cut stone. Great rivers of molten metal run throughout the "great forge" of the city, dwarfing the inhabitants. A dwarven dam built nearby is on the scale of the Hoover dam but the water erupts out of the dam to the valley below through the open mouths of truly monumental dwarven heads. The visual result, even with the resolution limitations of the WoW engine, is quite overpowering and impressive. Traveling from the dwarven realm to the realm of the night elves reveals that where the dwarven architecture is all about precision, power and colossal scale, the architecture of the night elves is thoroughly organic and radiates a balance with nature that is palpable. The elvish buildings meld and merge into the general woodland scenery. The scale of things is modest and the structures open and airy. The difference in architectural style is well thought out and I actually find it to be mood-affecting. In the dwarven realm I tend to be more aggressive and direct as I interact with the WoW world, while in the elven realms I tend to be more sneaky and laid back. Everything is green and brown and dappled with muted lighting which filters through foliage. I have to assume the above things are intentional, and as such, I have to give kudos to the desgners and implementers of the game. I believe that they have set out to create pretty much exactly the reaction that they get from me, and when taking the Cosmic Daughter through realm after realm, from her reaction I could tell that the effect was more or less the same for her as it was for me. The main reason I am so impressed by all this visual detail and the planning and thinking that went into it is that most of it is superfluous to the game engine and game mechanics, and as such they game designers really didn't need to put that much thought and effort into it. That they did demonstrates to me that the WoW design and implementation team take great pride in their creation, and imho, rightly so.

WoW update #3

By CosmicConservative
Yeah, I know it's only been a few days since update #2... I haven't actually spent that much time on WoW the last few days. I was on and off last night while doing chores and getting ready for the Cosmic Wife's return. But I didn't really do anything but some mining and some help for another player who is starting a character on the same server. The night before I did some significant questing for three hours or so, and as such I managed to advance to level 30, but I'm no longer pushing myself or my character to rush up the level advancement tree. I'm feeling sort of comfortable at level 30, it's high enough to feel safe while roaming around most places, but low enough to still feel like there are still lots of mountains to climb. I'm in no rush now to get to level 60+, but I do still feel a sense of some urgency to get up to level 39 so I can partner up with jSullins' druid and engage in some activities such as player vs. player arena stuff. I've now gotten my skills to be more or less level-appropriate for my character so I can make some fairly nice armor and weapons. I'm making some cash selling that on the auction site, which also makes me feel a bit more comfortable playing the game. My main activity going forward is going to be much more analytical and pragmatic. My goal is to maximize my character's level-appropriate combat abilities. In other words I am now far more interested in being the BEST level 30 rogue I can be than I am in moving on to level 31. My experience in PvP was humiliating enough, I don't intend to repeat it. Next time I engage in PvP I intend to be competitive. This does mean lots of practice with different techniques and attack combinations to see how to maximize their potential, so that will keep me moving up the level tree, but that's no longer the goal, it's more gravy. I also started another character with the intention of having it available to group with the Cosmic Daughter's character or other similar level characters. It's a little gnome mage that is just so goofy that I can't quite take the character seriously. It's quite interesting to play a gnome. You start out in an area heavily populated with dwarfs, and it is a new experience to have dwarfs loom over you like some sort of hulking behemoth. Regular humans or elves will likely appear to be gigantic monsters whose heads disappear into the clouds. Of course in the interest of fairness gnomes move as fast as any other character, but because of their perspective it feels like you are really zipping along at a fast rate, while my night elf seems to be strolling along at a leisurely gait in comparison. I think I'm more or less done with the heavy up-front time investment to get my first character to a decent playable level. Sure I'd like to have a 65th level rogue, but I'm no longer in any great hurry to get there.

WOW Update #2

By CosmicConservative
OK, so Dadman challenges my "Mr. Mom" update suggesting that my lack of blogging is due to a bleary-eyed compulsive addiction to World of Warcraft, so I felt like it was time to post an update to my WoW activities just to be fair. Plus, it's been a lot of fun. OK, so first to come clean about my time investment. I haven't been keeping track, but my best estimate is that I've spent about 2-3 hours per day playing WoW, which is fairly consistent with my old days in EverQuest. I think that will settle down to a smaller number once I'm done power-leveling my character to a reasonably fun playing level, which I'm actually pretty close to now. Right now my main character is at level 28, a level that would likely have taken two months to reach in EQ with the same daily time investment. So that's a good thing I think. I have to say that WoW is a whole lot more fun at low levels than EQ was. EQ was actually quite boring and slow-paced at the lowest levels. I still remember the days of killing rats and spiders to try to get enough XP and cash to actually get a decent sword or staff and some clothes other than rags. In WoW you get decent clothes, weapons and armor even at first level and you don't feel like a destitute homeless person who has to kill rats to live. So that's a good thing. EQ was not fun at all until you were in your teens. WoW feels like that right off the bat. The immediate impact of this is that in EQ it was an absolute chore to create a new character, but in WoW it's actually sort of fun, so that encourages players to experiment with races and classes. That's got to be good for WoW as a game. OK, back to my specific character. Up until Saturday I had been strictly "power-leveling" my character. "Power-leveling" has different meanings and connotations depending on who you talk to, but to me it means that I have been systematically pursuing those things that I believe will advance the character in levels as quickly as possible. It also means that I have not turned down help that has been offered by higher level characters. My goal was to get the character to a high enough level that I can start to participate in the more difficult and entertaining activities, such as "Player vs. Player" gaming (more on that later). I tend to be a single-minded sort of person when I get my focus on an issue. The positive side of that is that I can focus a lot of time and effort on a project. The down side of that is that I sometimes get so focused on a specific goal that I lose sight of the bigger picture. That's sort of what happened with power-leveling. I was so into the process of climbing up the level ladder with this character, that my original goal of "making a fun character to play" got sort of lost and I didn't really get back to that until Friday or Saturday of last week, when I realized that I had completely neglected the character's skills, talents and other character development things. By then the character was at level 26. So since then I have more or less changed my focus completely, and as such my level advancement has slowed to a crawl. Mostly I've been developing skills and professions, as well as working on specific means of making money in the game. Focusing on skills and professions is not completely counter-productive when it comes to leveling, but leveling becomes a totally secondary activity. For example, my character's basic profession is "mining" and as such my character has to go prospecting for mineral deposits, and then has to go there and dig the minerals out of the ground. Sometimes that means simply walking around and digging stuff up, but on occasion it means having to kill a bunch of mobs who are camped right on top of the mineral deposit. So if the mobs happen to be a high enough level to give experience when you kill them, then you get XP from the clearing out of the mobs. In this way I managed to crawl up a couple more levels. Eventually you reach a point that you have to mine rarer minerals and have to roam farther afield, and then the prospecting and leveling become more compatible. Because I neglected mining for so long I had to go back to areas where the mobs were such a low level that I didn't even get XP for clearing them out. Now I'm mostly mining tin which tends to be found in higher level areas so I'm back to getting some XP as I prospect. Next up is silver... My character's other profession is smithing. Right now all I can make is basic boring copper or brass armor and weapons. I have to work my way up to iron, and then to steel. I doubt I'll be able to make much money selling stuff until I am able to make and sell steel weapons or armor. In a sense it's sort of odd, my character is a rogue, and rogues can only wear leather armor, but the only armor I can make is mail armor, which means I can't actually wear anything that I make. I don't know if that's a good thing or not, but it does mean that my character will focus entirely on armor that can be SOLD not worn. Which may be a good thing. I can use the weapons I make though, although I can't yet make weapons that are as good as the ones I either get from quests or can buy. As I said, I neglected my professions and skills. So my goal now is to get all of my profession and skills maxed out and keep them that way as I get back to leveling as a goal. And then last night I discovered Player vs. Player arena battles. And I suck at it. I was getting totally wiped out in embarrassing ways. I wasn't totally useless, I was able to take out some opposing characters and was able to win one of the "capture the flag" scenarios I was involved with, but lost the other two. I was the target of more than a few "n00b" comments so I know that my incompetence was noted. And anyone who knows me should know how intolerable I find this to be. It is not in my nature that I have to be the BEST at everything, but at least I do expect myself to be COMPETENT at anything I do. And right now I'm far from competent in player vs. player combat on WoW. I've gotten to where I can take down a mob without much trouble and really only get into trouble when three or more mobs of equal or higher level swarm me. But in PvP I have been taken out of action by a single opponent with humiliating ease. I clearly have a LOT to learn still about how to fight. Anyway, that's about where I am now. The past couple of days I have really slowed down my game play. I may have the game up but my character is frequently just standing around next to an anvil or a forge. I'm spending a lot more time waiting and thinking than I did the first couple of weeks. All in all I have to say that WoW is a much superior game to EverQuest. Blizzard obviously checked out EQ and determined what worked and what didn't. They made the things that did not work, work better and made sure that all the stuff that did work was carried over. It is no wonder that there was a mass defection from EQ to WoW and that you almost never hear about EQ anymore. More later, maybe.

WoW update #1

By CosmicConservative
OK, so it's been a week, more or less, since I logged into World of Warcraft using their ten-day trial edition. I now have a three month subscription. That didn't take long, did it? I have not, until now, been very effective nor efficient in my utilization of my time on WoW. I first created a character on a randomly selected server, not thinking about needing to be aligned with people I already knew. Then I developed that character (a night elf druid) up to about level 9 in the first two days before I thought about hooking up with existing folks. Then I did contact a co-player and recreated that same character on a second server, again taking a couple of days to get that one up to about level nine again. So four days or so into the experiment I had two roughly equivalent characters. Then I learned that yet another friend had an account on yet ANOTHER server and so I created a THIRD character (this one a night elf rogue) on a THIRD server. Then I spent a couple of days developing that one up, but THIS time that friend actually found me and showed me some things to speed up my development. So I've been spending most of my time on that server now. As such I managed to get my rogue up to level 17 so far. Saturday evening I was planning on learning some great new stuff with my buddy when I encountered multiple connection failures and ended up having to reinstall the entire game from scratch, then go through all the online updates, a process that took about five hours, and pretty much wiped out my game playing for the whole day. Then, yesterday evening, as I was contemplating some level grinding to continue the rogue's career, the Cosmic Daughter logged in under the trial account and so I spent most of the evening helping her get her character leveled up and learning about the game. The end result is that after a week I'm only level 17 when if I had focused all of my energies on nothing but developing this one character, I estimate I'd be somewhere around level 25 now. Which is the FIRST great difference between WoW and the old EverQuest I played a few years ago. Level 17 was not something you could reach in a couple of days on EverQuest. Not unless you were playing up to ten hours per day instead of playing during the evening. I estimate I've averaged just under two hours per day for the first week. So I've probably spent sixteen or so hours on the game since I first used the trial account. (Actual game time elapsed will be much higher, I have left it running while doing chores, cooking dinner, watching some TV, blogging, etc. But actual game play time has not been all that high so far). I'm trying to put some parameters on game time so that I don't get caught in a WoW time-sink. I am planning on setting 10:30 as a hard stop each night on the game (on weeknights anyway) so that I don't stay up 'til 1:30 and then get up and go to work after four hours of sleep. I have done that sort of thing just blogging before, so I know it's a possibility for something as addictive as an online multi-player video game. My thoughts after the first week are as follows:
Wow! This game is so much like EverQuest that it's scary. Virtually all of the basic game mechanics are identical. Even to the point of collecting items in bags, banking them, emailing in-game and developing skills and trades. Many of the same keyboard commands are the same or almost the same as EverQuest. So in many ways it feels like starting over on EQ. The graphics are a bit better, but definitely not a whole new generation of graphics as I had sort of expected. EQ II graphics are far beyond anything I've seen in Wow so far. The game mechanics with the level grind, the skill development, the unending mindless quests, all of that could have been lifted straight from EQ and would have fit right in. So what's different about WoW compared to EQ? Well, I touched on one of the differences already. The first and most important is how much more quickly you level up. It feels like rocket speed compared to EQ. In the orginal EQ when you started out you literally were killing rats and spiders to survive and advance. You were lucky if you could score a rusty sword or a functioning bow. In WoW you start out with fairly decent equipment, and you can quickly find new equipment to replace your existing equipment (although why a razor-back hog would be carrying a pair of leather leggings is yet to be explained in EITHER game). The second difference is how quickly you recover your stats in WoW compared to EQ. In EQ if my wizard used up all his mana in a battle, he first had to sit down to recover it, and it might take five minutes to get it all back. It was not at all uncommon for me to sit the wizard down, and then fold clothes, cook dinner, make a phone call, or whatever while waiting for his mana to recharge. In WoW it is rare for me to have to wait more than a few seconds between encounters and the abilities recharge while I am moving, so there's very little delay between encounters. Also in WoW the number of "mobs" (an acronym of sorts for "mobile object" used to describe all manner of creatures or non-player characters) which are available is an order of magnitude beyond EQ. It was not uncommon on a busy server in EQ to wander around for ten minutes looking for things to fight to develop some XP. In WoW if you aren't moving, you will find the mob you just dispatched spawning right back on top of you. In EQ you could clear out an entire cave and come back twenty minutes later and it would still be cleared out. In WoW by the time you get to the boss fight in the center of the cave, the guards at the entrance are already back and you have to fight your way back out. One cave I am working on right now respawns so quickly that I have not been able to take out the second tier of guards before the first tier respawns, effectively surrounding me and attacking from all sides. I estimate their respawn rate at about two minutes. You have to move fast and you have to take the mobs down in quick succession. You don't spend a lot of time agonizing over strategy, or else you'll spend a lot of time searching for your body. So in general the fundamental game mechanic and look and feel is virtually identical to WoW, but the pace of play is ten times as fast. And overall, this is a good thing. It's a heap more fun than wandering around a desolate plain with several other desperate newbies hoping to be the first one to see the lone spawning rat or skeleton you need to get the piddling XP you gain so that you can one day hope to get out of the newbie zone.
That's about the best I can do so far. Let me get to level 30 or so and I may have a different opinion about the game. ;)

WoW, did I really just do that?

By CosmicConservative
About three years ago, back when I still thought my financial future was more than a gaping maw of despair and misery, I splurged on a one-year account on the massively multiplayer online role-plyaing game, (MMORPG) "Everquest." It wasn't the first online game I had played. I had played some online board games like Chess, some text-based role-playing games (I think those are now referred to as "MUDs") and even used to fly in a squadron in the online version of Jane's World War II Fighters simulation. Man that last one was fun. Seriously fun. But when I looked at Everquest I thought that perhaps this was finally an online version of a role-playing game that would allow me to merge three of my greatest recreational enjoyments. (Computers, Role Playing and Being Shut Up In A Tiny Little Room All By Myself For Hours). And at first it was a lot of fun, thus the splurge for the one-year account. Well, I had a few friends who played online and they were members of a Guild (The Dragonriders Guild) and soon I found myself vaulted into the upper tier of MMORPG gaming. My wizard was almost 60th level and my fighter was just a few levels behind. Every night was an opportunity to get together and kick the bejeebuz out of some virtual creatures and save the virtual universe. And it wasn't long before it BECAME every night there was something to do. In Everquest if you weren't actively kicking some digital butt, you were crafting some virtual stuff to sell to finance your digital butt kicking, since adventuring, even in the digital realm, is not nearly as profitable as you might imagine. Spinning spider silk into cloth is actually a much more dependable way to make digital money. Or fishing for digital codfish. Soon I found my digital avatar standing idly by the digital seashore, digitally flinging my digital bait and hook into the digital sea in an effort to catch some rare digital delicacy that I could sell in the digital market for more digital cash so I could buy my character more powerful digital doodads. Or to put it mildly, DIGITALLY WORKING. But you really had no choice if you wanted to be able to keep up with the digital Joneses. So you did it. Then Everquest came out with a WHOLE NEW VERSION, with BETTER GRAPHICS and NEW CLASSES, etc. So since my subscription covered any Sony game, I started playing Everquest II. The digital economy in EQ II was more sophisticated than in EQ I. No longer was my best money-making scheme roaming around the digital sea shore fishing for digital fish, no, in EQ II I had to get a REAL job. Soon enough I was an apprentice alchemist. My "job" was to take raw materials and convert them into refined materials. So for example I might find some digital nuts or twigs laying on the digital ground and take them back to my digital basement shop and digitally grind and boil them down to some key chemical that was needed to make a digital potion that could then be sold to digital adventurers who needed to improve their digital powers. Soon enough I found my digital self slaving away in the alchemy workshop more often than he was roaming around the world. In fact I soon realized that I had formed an actual schedule to balance the two. Sunday mornings while the rest of the Cosmic family was at church, I would slog through as much alchemical processing as possible, selling as much as I could to finance my weekly adventuring as I inched slowly up the level chain. But I could not keep up. Even devoting an entire Sunday morning each week to the digital alchemy bench, I was falling further and further behind my peers in the guild. "What do these people DO with their lives?" I would ask as I logged on and one of my guildmates had mysteriously and miraculously gained two levels seemingly overnight, while my character's progress bar had barely budged in spite of the creation of bushel baskets full of refined nutmeg I had suffered over and sold for just enough to upgrade my "rusty dagger" to a shiny new "iron dagger". Then something happened that caused my digital self to raise my digital eyes from the digital workbench. Something called "World of Warcraft" had been announced and was stealing Guild members from our Everquest community. Soon the trickle became a flood and many of our most powerful members were no longer logging on. The Guild suffered an existential crisis, as did most of the Everquest community at large. And in the confusion and chaos I packed my digital butt up and logged off for good. And I've never regretted it. Oh, I had a lot of fun on Everquest I anyway. I have to admit that I really didn't enjoy Everquest II very much. The graphics were phenomenal, but the game itself had become more of a burden than a joy. I found myself logging on late at night "just to get a few more ingredients refined" so that I wasn't totally left behind by my peers. Eventually I estimated that I was spending twice as much time in the alchemy basement workshop than I was roaming the world looking for adventure. Plus my internet connection back then was unreliable and slow, so I found myself getting kicked off right at a critical moment, resulting in days worth of material manufacture getting lost in the aether as the connection broke just as I was attempting to craft something special. Logging back in usually revealed the components to be used up, and the effort to have failed to produce the desired result (this is because the craft mechanism in EQ II was heavily based on attention and reaction. So making something like a jeweled ring required hundreds of original components being refined repeatedly until you had the final material components necessary to craft the final ring, and then the process required monitoring the effort closely and hitting certain key or mouse strokes during the minutes-long manufacturing process to "fine tune" the process. If you lost connection, the server simply thought you weren't paying attention and your beautiful ring ended up being a shapeless mass of metal). So after all of that, why is it that I found myself downloading and playing the free ten day WoW teaser last night? Now I've got a level 9 druid... I will say that so far at least my druid has had nothing but fun and adventure. But starting around level seven she's been getting these little hints and reminders that she really needs to choose a profession... So I'm asking some of my WoW using buddies how mind-numbing the WoW crafting system is. Am I going to play beyond the ten days? Honestly? Probably. God help me.

Game Review: D&D 4e

By CosmicConservative
Well, I promised a review of the latest release of Dungeons and Dragons from Wizards of the Coast. Today I played in a four hour session that took us through three encounters with various NPCs. It's different. Very different. I knew from the hints and excerpts that had been released on the message boards that it was going to be different, and I had mentally prepared myself for it to be more or less an entirely new experience. My main goal in going to the "demo" game in the first place was to get some idea if I was going to enjoy it enough to keep moving forward with the game, or stick with the version I already knew and enjoyed. The game was started after six players gathered around the table and the Wizards-sanctioned GM (Game Master) sat at the table, complete with a "D&D 4E" hat on. After a short round of introductions, we listened while the GM gave us (and the crowd of about a dozen interested non-players who were watching the game) a description of some of the major differences between the existing game, and the new version. This took a fair amount of time because of the questions that were asked, many coming from the people standing around the table. The players, including me, were itching to get into the game. Next the GM handed out a sheet of 4e highlights which described in a short paragraph or two the basic game mechanics. I don't think I'm supposed to republish them here, so I'll just say that the attempts to simplify the game were apparent in many areas. This has been an ongoing trend with the game, every release attempts to simplify the basic mechanics more than the previous release, with varying degrees of success. Reading through the description it seemed that some of it would be quite clearly an improvement, while other aspects seemed to oversimplify things too much and another set were just strange and would need to be played to figure them out. Basically the game is still turn-based and each player's turn is broken down into three actions, each of which can only be taken once (with some caveats). Those are as follows: 1. Standard Action: This is basically the same as older versions of the game. This is where a player character does the basic activity of their turn, such as opening a chest, casting a spell, firing a weapon, or taking a swing at an opponent. This is the "highest level" of the three actions. 2. Move Action: This is also basically the same as the older versions of the game. As it sounds this action is basically an action where a character is repositioned according to the limitations they have in their ability to move. Movement is now square based but this is an area they have simplified to the extreme. On a square grid you can now move in any direction as many squares as your character can move in one move action, regardless of whether you are moving vertically, horizontally or diagonally. In the old rules diagonal moves cost more than vertical or horizontal moves, but apparently the math and geometry-challenged players or game designers felt that this was too complicated for today's game players to manage. My personal opinion is that if they wanted to make it this simple, they should have gone with a hexagonal grid instead of a square one. That way the movement is more or less realistic, where with the square based grids moving diagonally you move roughly 1.4 times as far as moving horizontally or diagonally. This sacrifice of common sense to the pursuit of simplicity just bugs me on so many levels that I can't even go into it. 3. Minor Action: In the old rules there were a variety of "minor actions" ranging from a free action to a swift action. Each had its own rules. I actually like this modification, because in the old rules it was sometimes difficult to determine what combinations of major and minor move actions could be legitimately attempted in one turn. Also a "standard action" can be replaced by either of the two "lower" actions, and a "move action" can be replaced by a "minor action." Which means that a character could do three minor actions if they preferred, and that would fill their turn, or two move actions and a minor action. Next the GM handed out a set of pre-created characters, and we worked out which character we would play. I ended up playing a "Ranger" which is intended to be a sort of outdoorsy combat specialist who favors ranged weapons over melee ones. The sheet was one page, front and back, and listed all of the possible actions the Ranger could take. It also listed the Ranger's attributes, most of which were either the same as, or comparable to older versions. For example, each character is still based around the venerable attribute scores of Strength, Dexterity, Constitution, Intelligence, Wisdom and Charisma. A new twist on the character sheets was the breakdown of the character's abilities. Some abilities were "at will" meaning they could be used at any time by the character. Others were "per encounter" meaning they were limited to a finite number of uses during an encounter (all were "1 per encounter" uses). And each character had at least one "per day" ability, again, all of the characters were limited in their daily abilities to a "once per day" use. Basically an "encounter" is any set of activities that happens between "short rests" of at least five game minutes, and a "day" is any set of activities that happen between "long rests" of at least six hours. Short rests reset "per encounter" abilities and long rests reset "per day" abilities. Simple enough, but this was definitely new. With that we began to play the game. The GM explained that our group of adventurers was more or less on the outs with the local authorities, and had been hired to deliver a sealed scroll to a local merchant in the town. We were all cooling our heels in the local tavern waiting for the merchant to signal that it was safe for us to approach him, when he would give us the remaining half of our fee for delivering the scroll, and we could then be on our way. Of course that's not what happened. The merchant was suddenly approached by a group of men dressed as village guards and a man in robes carrying a staff. The GM announced that this group of men was demanding that the merchant (who had our fee still) surrender to them, then announced that we needed to "roll for initiative" which is the time-honored signal for the beginning of an "encounter." Our wizard won the initiative and his first action was to attempt to put the oncoming party of "guards" to sleep with his "once per day" ability. He was partially successful as four of the six dropped to the ground. The rest of our group, figuring that the guards would not appreciate having been the target of a spell, decided our best course of action was to hit them first and hard before they could attack us. D&D is described as a "role playing game" and in the early days, it was considered to be something of an insult to call someone a "roll player" meaning that they were more interested in the tactical aspects of the encounters and all the ways to roll dice to beat up their opponents. With each release of the game "roll playing" has been elevated until it was roughly equal to "role playing" in 3.5. In this release the attention to "roll playing" has been such that the "roll playing" now seems to be more central to the game than the "role playing." This was evident in our first battle as the game mechanics dictated virtually all of the actions. Now, that's not entirely a bad thing. In fact it may not be a bad thing at all. The increasing importance of "roll playing" in the game has always been to decrease the unpleasantness of having GMs and players argue about such things as whether a target is within range, has some sort of cover or is or is not vulnerable to a particular approach. For that reason it is imperative in today's gaming community that the game mechanics drive the action in a smooth, predictable and decisive manner. This, in fact, was one of the things that I was most interested in checking out by playing in the demo game. The first encounter was not smooth. But that was more due to the players' attempts to play the game as if it were still under the old rules, and our unfamiliarity with our own characters' abilities. In fact in that first encounter even the GM misunderstood a fairly basic rule around my (and our warlock's) basic use of our main minor action. But the encounter proceeded briskly even with those minor confusions. And soon we had defeated the "guards" and my character was tying up the leader for questioning. But at that moment the remaining sleeping "guard" awakened and began yelling for help from the real town guards. My character barely had time to snatch a curious dagger from the leader before we were forced to flee an oncoming phalanx of actual guards. Now this is important. In the older versions of D&D the rules around melee or ranged combat have always been fairly well done, well enough to satisfy millions of fans anyway. But one area that has always been "broken" has been such things as having a group of player characters attempt to flee from, or pursue a group of non-player characters. The new version addresses this situation directly with a set of rules for determining the success or failure of group actions such as hiding, running, obstructing or sneaking. Our group attempted all of those things. The rules for such a situation seem to be that the players' group needs to be successful in four attempts at such group actions before they fail at four attempts. Success means they achieve their objective (whether that is hiding, fleeing or obstructing, for example). Failure does not mean that they are captured, but it means something negative happens. We failed four times and succeeded three times. The GM ruled that the outcome of the activity was that we successfully evaded capture, but not before the guards had seen us well enough to identify us later. I have mixed feelings about this though. At one point our party was running through a corn field and we managed to set the corn ablaze behind us as we ran, forcing the pursuing guards to either rush through the flames, or rush around them, either of which should have given us enough of an advantage that we could have escaped or hidden. But the GM simply ignored the flames and continued the pursuit as if they had never been set. This sort of arbitrary ignoring of physical reality by a GM always bothers me, but I don't think that is a flaw in the new rules, I just think the GM was not being realistic and did not consider the likely actual reaction of a group of men in armor rushing headlong into a burning corn field. You see this sort of thing a lot in GMs actually, no matter what version of the game you are playing. After a short rest, we continued on into our second encounter which was against a group of undead skeletons, including one which was aflame, and one which could explode bone fragments from its body doing serious damage for a wide area. This encounter led to the most significant rules debate of the session when our warlock used his daily ability against the exploding skeleton. The description of the ability said that with a successful hit, besides doing direct damage to the target, the warlock could "slide" the creature three squares. The question raised was whether the "slide" allowed the warlock to move the creature in any direction, or if it only moved directly away from the warlock. My position in the discussion was that other actions which caused the target to move directly away from the player character described the reaction as "pushed back", and so "slide" was either a simple wording error, or else was intended to mean a specific sort of action. And in fact "slide" IS a specific action and a "slide" can go in any direction. The GM finally ruled as I had hoped, and our warlock was able to push the exploding skeleton off a cliff, disposing of the greatest threat to the party. We quickly mopped up the rest of the undead combatants. During that battle we almost lost two of our group. Our halfling paladin was set aflame and actully remained on fire for most of the encounter, leading to a lot of jokes at his expense. The halfling and our cleric both were brought to the brink of death multiple times, only to be brought back by other characters jeopardizing their own lives to save them. Until the warlock pushed the exploding one off the cliff, we were all convinced that we would be killed. The GM assured us that many other groups who played this demo did not survive this encounter. But we did, although it was a close thing. After that encounter the GM took pity on us and went around the table taking four of our group's character sheets and explaining in some detail how their abilities could be better utilized and made to work in synergy with the other characters' abilities. Unfortunately he had no suggestions for me since the Ranger seems to be a fairly simple character to play, and I had already used all of his abilities more or less as the GM would have suggested them to be used. Which sort of disappointed me because it implied that the Ranger was not as resourceful as the other characters. After that we took a full rest, recovered all of our abilities and hit points and went on our way where we had our final encounter, this one the GM said was the hardest of the three. Either our group is a fast learning group, or we got lucky in this encounter because it ended up being somewhat easier than the fight against the undead. Our opponents in this case were four human berserkers, an elf wizard and some sort of chain-weilding humanoid whose ability to attack multiple opponents was rechargable after use if the player (or GM in this case) rolled a six on a six-sided die. The GM rolled three sixes, recharging the ability three times. Even so the battle was relatively short and devoid of threats of total party destruction, and after we dispatched them all, we called it a day. So, my thoughts on the new game are: It's different. They have simplified some things that needed to be simplified, which makes the game better, but they also simplified some things that did NOT need to be simplified, which makes the game worse. I thought I would dislike the new mechanism of developing character abilities. Actually I sort of like the new mechanism. The daily, encounter and at will approach was surprisingly effective, both in terms of using them in battle, and in terms of keeping track of what your character can do. In the old rules it is not at all uncommon for the player of a spell-casting character to spend several minutes contemplating what to do before actually committing to a single action. From a game play dynamic, this is very bad because it slows down the game and causes other players to get bored. And bored people get up and walk around, which means when the slow player finally makes up their mind, someone has to go hunt down the next player so the game can continue. Such things sometimes take up a large fraction of an encounter. With the new approach that was not really a problem. In four hours we had three significant encounters and this was our group's FIRST TIME to use the new rules, so there was significant loss of time asking questions just due to our inexperience. My feeling is that the new rules move much quicker than the old rules, which is a very good thing in my mind. Other than the oversimplification of movement, distance and area of effect spells, the main concern I have with the new rules is one that may only be true of this demo, and that is the lack of "buffing". In the old rules a clever player can gain tremendous tactical advantages in an encounter through the judicious application of spells or effects which enhance certain attributes or abilities. I am a big fan of this because it makes the encounters more than a hack and slash exercise. I enjoy the contemplation of tactics and strategies that frequently can mean the difference between success and failure based on careful analysis of the situation and proper utilization of magic or effects. This is one of the main areas I feel that smarter, more experienced players have an advantage over dumber or less experienced ones. There was basically none of that in this session. I hope that is not true of the entire game. I'll find out when the new books come. The most important question of all, and the one I went to answer, was whether the new rules were worth the effort to move to them. Overall I was left with enough of a positive reaction that I am willing to give it a try. I can't say I am overly enthusiastic, but overall I was pleased with the results. The bottom line is that it was a fun session.

First star party of 2008

By CosmicConservative
So tonight I ended up helping out at a star party held at an elementary school down in the Denver flatlands. As we neared Denver we realized that the clouds were gathering, the wind was howlling, and we might just not have much luck. By the time we got set up and the sun was starting to go down, there was nothing but a little strip of clear sky above the mountains to the west, the rest of the sky was socked in. By the time the kids came out of the presentation to use the actual telescopes, we were having trouble finding a single star in the sky. We finally found one and had literally a hundred kids (and some teachers and parents) lined up at four telescopes (two of which were mine) to look at a single star in a telescope. My refractor finally was able to see three or four stars, and the kids got real excited about that. But that's a pretty lame way to have a star party. Then the clouds really rolled in and we packed up and headed the fifty miles back to the house. That's when the car overheated. Three times. What a night...

Geeky concerns about new version of D&D

By CosmicConservative
So most of you can just skip this. Dungeons and Dragons 4.0 is due out on June 6th. Not a day I would have chosen to launch a new version of the venerable role-playing game. Now it's D&D on D-Day... Nicely alliterative, but not necessarily the image you really want to visualize. Here's a picture of their new Players Handbook: I'm sure I've mentioned before what an unrepentant geek I am, and no doubt that makes some readers uncomfortable, but hey, this is still my blog and on occasion I'm going to post some personal interest stuff just because I can. But I'll hide it behind a <more> tag to spare most readers. So As I said, June 6, D-Day, is D&D 4e day. (The "e" stands for "Edition"). D&D has been through several versions over the 30 or so years it has been around. It originally started as a variation of a miniature-based war game, but instead of pieces on a board and a lot of charts and dice-rolling rules you got pieces on a board and a lot of charts and dice-rolling rules with role-playing!. Why did this make a difference? Well, I'm sure there have been numerous doctoral dissertations on this subject. I think it was because when you created a unique character and started loading him/her/it down with stuff you found, won or bought during the campaigns you were in, it allowed the player to identify with the character as a virtual version of themselves, instead of just a piece on a game board. Through all the revisions of the game, that core concept has remained the major attraction of the game to me. I enjoy creating complex "backstories" for my characters, narratives of their lives, their families, their motivations and their experiences before and during their career as virtual versions of myself wandering through imaginary worlds as they encounter and overcome challenges. It's sort of like writing a novel, but without total editorial control, so even the "author" doesn't know where things are really going to go. I am one of those geeks who has a box full of stuff related to the game. I've got notebooks full of maps and characters who populate the worlds I've created, and other notebooks full of characters I have played over the years in worlds created by OTHER gamers. Some of those characters eventually became so powerful that it was difficult to find any sort of playable challenges for them. I mean when you can summon and defeat the great demon-lord Azmodius, what else are you going to fight? It's sort of the Superman conundrum, you have to start creating opponents with god-like powers, and then the battles become virtually impossible to manage as the combatants manipulate the very fabric of space and time. So I tend to play lower-level characters, characters who still have to sneak around on tip-toes to avoid waking up the goblin guards at the wrong time, and who are at real risk of actually being killed by a lucky arrow or two. Right now I am playing in two campaigns, and am running a third campaign myself. My characters are third and fourth level, which means they are still weak enough that they would have to be careful if a mob of angry townspeople decided to gang up on them. At that level each time you advance to a new level, it feels like a butterfly emerging from a cocoon. Gaining new powers or enhancing existing ones just makes you want to try them out on some unsuspecting dungeon dwellers... And that's the problem, see... With this latest upgrade to the game rules, the rumors are rampant that the designers have thrown away so much of the old game that it will be impossible to convert existing 3.5e characters into 4e characters, and so my active characters will simply become frozen in time, living forever in a notebook between clear plastic protective sheets. I'm hoping that's not the case. And to find out if it is or not, I have managed to get to play in a Fourth Edition sneak preview game this weekend. That means I'll get to roll up a fourth edition character, outfit him or her and put them through a campaign to see how it all works. Many die-hard 3.5e fans swear they will never buy the new books and will stick with their comfortable old rules, and that's fine. But I have found that over time that strategy just ends up with fewer and fewer players and fewer and fewer options. So I have already pre-ordered the books so that I'll get them as soon as they hit the shelves. Of course that means I now have a vested interest in actually liking the new rules. So I am hoping I do. I'll give you all an update when I get through.

Book Review: Titan

By CosmicConservative
by John Varley I guess this is a pretty old book. The copyright date on it is 1979. Somehow I never got around to reading it. Hmm.... It's sci-fi, by the way, so you might want to skip down to the Daily 'Toon if you're not into sci-fi. Since the book is almost 30 years old, I guess I can talk about it without worrying about spoilers. I'm not sure why I picked this up. Perhaps the blurb on the back saying that John Varley was a Hugo and Nebula award winner was enough to get my attention. Then all the review snippets talking about how this was the next big thing in sci-fi probably had an impact too. My reaction after reading the book? "meh." It's a decent read, but nothing special. The fundamental story may have seemed unique and original to readers 30 years ago, but it comes across as tired and derivative to me. And I don't mean derivative of things from the last 30 years, I mean derivative of things like "2001 A Space Odyssey" or "The Wizard of Oz" even. Basically the story is about a spaceship with a crew of seven sometime in the late 21st century which is exploring the Saturnian system. To make along story short, they discover an artifact in orbit around Saturn, but it's a huge artifact, with the "lowest albedo in the Solar System" to explain why it hasn't been detected by earth or by probe for 300 years. But it's HUGE, like 3,000 kilometers wide or so. I guess the author never considered that the thing would have had to cross Saturn's brightly lit face every month or so, making it clearly visible even to backyard astronomers like me. But that's perhaps being a bit too picky... The artifact captures the spaceship and kidnaps the crew. The spaceship is destroyed and the crew is put through a disturbing "rebirth" scenario before being expunged into the artifact where they become explorers in a strange new world. The artifact is basically a huge torus with spokes leading from the inside of the torus to the hub. The now ship-less crew begin an odyssey (did I leave out "The Odyssey" in my derivative comment?) to try to figure out how to find the artifact's builders and discover why they were captured, and figure out how to get back to earth. But there's a lot of problems. One is that everyone in the crew except the protagonist, Captain Cirocco Jones, suffered severe mental damage in the rebirth process. Some have gone entirely insane. Others are just messed up. But not Cirocco. She's tough. After slogging through a lot of gratuitous sex and seriously disturbing sexual imagery of alien beings for a couple hundred pages of contrived conflict, Cirocco ("Rocky") and her new lesbian lover "Gaby" eventually reach the hub where they discover the incredible secret of the artifact. A secret that you will probably figure out by page 30. There's a seriously lame Wizard of Oz moment and then a reconciliation between the Artifact's builder or builders and Rocky, who actually accepts a job offer from the being or beings who have kidnaped her, almost killed her several times, mentally raped her and her entire crew, leading to her and Gaby being physically raped etc... But all is forgiven because Rocky had the adventure she had been craving her whole life. I don't generally wish I had never read a book, but I may make an exception in this case. The premise is so lame, the execution is so heavy-handed, the graphic sexual content is so gratuitous and frankly disturbing that it really does feel like this was time I wish I could get back. In case someone else actually wants to read it, I won't spoil it by revealing the "big amazing revelation" of the end, but if you haven't figured it out by page thirty, you're not really trying. I guess the lesson is that you can't judge a book from it's back-cover blurbs...