Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Politics

Tide turning on Miers?

By CosmicConservative
Hugh Hewitt continues to do a great job of shoring up the base on the Miers nomination. His original argument was that the majority of conservative resistance to Miers' nomination came from the "elite right" and was very similar to what was coming from the "elite left." He argued that the base didn't really care what school she attended, or whether she had studied ConLaw for ten years in solitude. Initial polls were lukewarm, providing neither support nor rebuttal for Hugh's argument. The past few days though there has certainly been a shift in the stories I've been reading. The opposition to Miers seems to be solidifying in the elite camps of both sides, while the base seems to be warming up to her. The two major arguments in her favor seem to be her attempt to get the ABA to revoke their official support of the Roe V. Wade decision and her vocal support of gun ownership as an individual right. The argument seems to go like this: "If she gets it right on abortion and gun control, chances are she'll get it right on eminent domain and the commerce clause." I remain in the undecided camp, but I also don't see much point in endlessly debating the nomination. The argument that Bush had an opportunity to push a much stronger conservative is pointless now for the following reasons: 1. Even if true, that ship has sailed. Whatever strategic or tactical advantage the Roberts' confirmation granted Bush was squandered the instant Miers' nomination was official. Even if Miers withdraws or is not confirmed, the political dynamic that was very much in Bush's favor on SCOTUS picks has now turned dramatically. 2. There is no way to know if Bush asked those "better picks" and was rebuffed. The vitriolic process that exists today to get confirmed is something a lot of people would simply rather not go through. Perhaps Miers was tenth on his list, but he got to #10. 3. It seems that many on the right are falling into the same trap that the left has been falling into since 2000. The "Bush is an idiot" argument has led to an incredible number of political defeats for Bush's opponents. Time after time Bush's political acumen has proven to be brilliant. It seems a bit churlish after years of snickering at the "misunderestimation" of GW Bush to suddenly be participating in it. I am looking forward to the hearings.

Columbus Day

By CosmicConservative
Today is the day the U.S. celebrates something... Either we celebrate the first voyage that initiated the "Age of Discovery" in Western Europe, or else we celebrate Italian heritage in general, I'm not sure which. For many people today is just another opportunity to protest against what they view as the hegemony of Western culture and the genocide of indigenous peoples all across the globe. That all seems too heavy for me, and I don't get the day off anyway, so it's hard to care much about the fuss one way or the other. I guess I'm not a great fan of the culture of the 15th century, a culture that seemed to too easily look the other way when great human tragedy was occurring, but there is always a tendency to judge the people of the past according to our own standards. I suppose it is only fair to speculate that five hundred years from now people will look back on the 21st century as some sort of backwards culture beset with tribalism, consumerism, and hell-bent on cultural suicide. At least I sort of hope that's what people 500 years in the future think about us. I'd hate to think that we have reached the pinnacle of cultural development for the human species in 2005. Assuming that to be true, is it reasonable for us to expect folks 500 years from now to celebrate Neil Armstrong and the first trip to the moon? Will parades in honor of the Apollo astronauts be plagued with protests against the industrialism and nationalism that led the U.S. to that great effort?

Miers

By CosmicConservative
I guess I will have to get into the act on the Harriet Miers nomination. I have had numerous conversations with folks on the left and the right, as well as those who somehow manage to remain more or less in the middle, and the overwhelming reaction to this nomination is negative. The general reaction from all sides is that this is rank cronyism. Perhaps it is. I am trying to reserve judgment until I actually see Ms. Miers perform in front of the Judiciary Committee. However, I truly am disappointed that one of the top picks on the right who have been taking all the shots from the left didn't get the opportunity to get their day in court, so to speak. But now that Miers is a nominee, my "official" position (that sounds so pretentious) is that we should judge her on the merits, not on what we wish had happened. So put me in the "undecided" column. For now. If there is one thing that led me to vote for GW Bush twice, it was this opportunity, and if he blows it, I am afraid that I will not be alone in my disgust for his administration and the Republicans in general. It seems clear to me that if the Senate Republicans had demonstrated the willpower and fortitude to stand up to the ideologues on the left, Bush would never have felt the need to nominate a stealth candidate. I was expecting a much more interesting second round for SCOTUS confirmation than the John Roberts experience, and it looks like that will be the case, but not for the reasons I expected.