I blame Rock and Roll...
George Will has a column today on the decline of manliness. (Yeah, I know you're thinking "George Will? Manliness?") Here's a quote:
Current economic hardships have had what is called in constitutional law a "disparate impact": The crisis has not afflicted everyone equally. Although women are a majority of the workforce, perhaps as many as 80 percent of jobs lost were held by men. This injury to men is particularly unfortunate because it may exacerbate, and be exacerbated by, a culture of immaturity among the many young men who are reluctant to grow up.
He then goes on to expound in great detail how "men" of today are mostly extended adolescents. He has lots of facts and data to back it up too. For example, in today's America women are the majority of doctors, lawyers and other traditionally "male" professions. Women make up the majority of college students and 58% of college graduates today are female. Females aged 18-25 are roughly 1/2 as likely to be living with their parents as males aged 18-25.
He blames this on a culture which has essentially betrayed men, while at the same time glorifying women. Men are portrayed as bumbling incompetents in most modern entertainment, especially sit-coms and movie comedies. He uses the example of Cary Grant and Hugh Grant as a means of describing how his generation watched movies where men were debonaire, cultured and mature, where our generation watches movies where men are bumbling arrested adolescents.
I'd say he has a point.
The biggest comedy of 2009 was "The Hangover" a movie about four "men" in their 30s who were off to Vegas to have a wild bachelor party for their buddy. Each of the men was portrayed as selfish, immature and irresponsible.
Will also contrasted television shows like "Friends" or "Seinfeld" with shows from his generation to demonstrate how our culture has created an extended immaturity. Adult men never grow up in these shows. They behave and talk at early middle age exactly as they did in high school. With the exception of Jerry in Seinfeld, none of the "men" in these shows can hold a job, provide for their family, remain in a monogamous relationship, or address their life problems in any sort of serious way. He only compared this to the ubiquitous Westerns of his generation, where men were heroic, stoic and focused on providing for, protecting and raising their families. I would even compare modern shows to early sit-coms like "The Odd Couple" or "The Courtship of Eddie's Father" or "The Dick Van Dyke Show" to demonstrate how different a 30-something was portrayed in the 50s and even 60s compared to today.
He doesn't say this, but he implies that we are at risk of losing an entire generation (or two) of men, and without men to raise children, the loss may perpetuate itself as boys are raised to believe that "men" should act like teenagers for the rest of their lives.
Will's penultimate paragraph suggests that this extended adolescence is compounded by the baby boomer's narcissistic fixation with their own past:
At the 2006 Super Bowl, the Rolling Stones sang "Satisfaction," a song older than the Super Bowl. At this year's game, another long-of-tooth act, the Who, continued the commerce of catering to baby boomers' limitless appetite for nostalgia. "My generation's obsession with youth and its memories," Cross writes, "stands out in the history of human vanity."
Now, I have to admit that this sort of thing hits me pretty close to home. I don't make any secret that I am, at age 50, still very much involved in gaming, an activity I think Will would sniff at as a perfect example of this extended adolescence. I can at least offset that by pointing out that I moved out of my house at age 17 and have lived on my own since then, I got married in my 20s and had kids, and my career has been pretty consistent with pre-baby boomer career paths (essentially the whole "climbing the corporate ladder" career thing), so I've done OK in the "provide for, protect and raise the family" thing. But I do spend a good bit of my "leisure" time pursuing my own selfish interests, such as fishing, stargazing, playing guitar, blogging, playing computer games, playing table-top games, etc.
Maybe I'm some sort of transitional form of "man" where I was raised to get a job, be serious and be "a man" but not quite enough to put aside "childish things." I've got a foot in both worlds, I suppose. Something to think about.