Stargazers thrilled by total lunar eclipse – CNN.com
Despite cloudy conditions over much of Europe, a variety of Webcasts carried the event live, and astronomers urged the public not to miss out on the spectacle.“It’s not an event that has any scientific value, but it’s something everybody can enjoy,” said Robert Massey, of Britain’s Royal Astronomical Society.
Italics are mine, by the way.
Now, last time I checked there are a number of scientific activities underway during a total lunar eclipse. Here are some I remember from off the top of my head.
1. The hue of the moon during a lunar eclipse provides scientists with an opportunity to study light reflected from the moon that has passed through the earth’s atmosphere. Deeper hues of red can indicate large amounts of dust in the air. Studying the spectrographs of the moon’s reflected light can help us understand better the composition of the atmosphere on earth. This has even been cited in Global Warming research.
2. The moon is usually too bright for astronomers to focus their big telescopes on anything close to the moon because the harsh light of the moon drowns out nearby obects. During a lunar eclipse the whole night sky is darkened, allowing a few more hours of serious astronomy to be done across the entire sky.
3. When I was in college physics, we used lunar (and solar) eclipse timings to do trivial things like calculate the size of the moon, sun and earth. These may be “old news” to a venerable RAS member, but they still qualify as “good science” even if only in the sense that it is good training for young scientists learning their trade.
I know there are more things that are done during lunar eclipses. I suspect that this RAS person knows it too, but was simply giving a simple, pat answer to a question he didn’t want to spend any real time on.
But it irks me when these things happens. Science is dissed enough already without some RAS astronomer telling kids that a lunar eclipse is just a boring event for “real” scientists.
3 users commented in " Lunar eclipse dissed by Royal Astronomical Society member "
Follow-up comment rss or Leave a TrackbackDude, it may be old news to them, but to any gradeschooler with a good physics/science teacher it’s a golden opportunity to guide them through the workings of astronomy and maybe allow them to discover something themselves.
(Discover in the same sense that Christopher Columbus is often derided for claiming the “discovery” of America. Yes, other people blundered onto the continent first, but it was a completely new find for Columbus and the rest of Europe!)
Dear All
The perils of the media… This quote was a contraction of a statement I made that lunar eclipses were less scientifically important to professional astronomers than total solar eclipses, but that there was still some work going on.
I’m very aware of the opportunities they present, albeit mostly for education, and actively encourage everyone to watch them. For the record I have also run many outreach events with children and adults that centred on lunar eclipses (for example in 2001 there was another eclipse that was well-timed for the UK and Greenwich where I then worked and where a couple of hundred visitors came along).
I’m disappointed that you think the RAS would suggest that these events are ‘boring’. In the interviews I did I explicitly stated that very many ‘real’ astronomers enjoy them too. If we really didn’t rate the eclipse we would not have included it in our monthly press release with the aim of promoting the event in the UK.
Regards
Robert Massey
[...] Some of you may recall my post on the CNN story about the Lunar eclipse last month. I was pretty critical of a Dr. Robert Massey, who was quoted in the CNN article saying “It’s not an event that has any scientific value”. [...]
Leave A Reply