
My aesthetic challenges are notorious here on CC, but I nonetheless still have opinions about aesthetics, even if they are those of an artistic philistine…
First I’ll address the timing of this. It’s yet another political unforced error by the Bumbler-in-Chief. It really doesn’t matter that the expense of this is not picked up directly by the taxpayers, nor that the office should be comfortable for the sitting President to facilitate better decision making. The reality is that not only was this done when a huge fraction of America is out of work and facing mortgage foreclosures, Obama had the additional tone-deafness to have this done while he was on yet another of his seemingly endless vacations. The message that sends is very much reinforcing the “Marie Antionette” image that he and Michelle seem determined to force down the throats of the American people. But the bottom line is that from a purely rational perspective, Obama has every right to do this, most other Presidents have done the same thing, and it’s really a tiny, tiny thing in the overall scheme of events and issues that we face today.
Now the room itself.
What’s with the stealth doors? I’ve never seen doors to an office blended into the background before. I find the outlines and doorknob sticking out of the wallpaper to be far more distracting and annoying than an actual door frame would be.
I don’t like the predominance of browns and beiges… Working in that office would just make me tired. I’d want to lay down and go to sleep. Those couches look too fluffy and comfortable too, just adding to the image of relaxation. They look more like dozing couches than working couches. I’m guessing the scene in the photo above is somewhat distorted by a fisheye camera lens. But the sense of staring down a gauntlet is pronounced in this view. I would prefer a more casual alignment of the couches and table to suggest that when engaged with the President, it’s more of a meeting of equals than a group of supplicants seeking approval.
The wallpaper sends me mixed messages. The muted brown and beige pattern suggests a casual and warm atmosphere, but the rigid striations marching around the room send the opposite message, especially with the harsh white paneling along the bottom third of the room.
And what’s with the single blue cushion? It feels like someone carried that in from the Lincoln bedroom and accidentally left it behind. I’m not a big fan of bunches of sofa cushions anyway, they just get in the way when you’re trying to actually use the sofas, unless you are taking a nap, in which case they are quite useful. I can’t help but look at the cushions and visualize a servant removing them from the room for every important meeting so they don’t end up tossed on the floor, and then bringing them back in for photo ops….
All in all I find the design to be sort of outdated. Some have called it a 1970s remake, but it’s not so much 1970s as it is the sort of color scheme and layout I’d expect in a starting attorney trying to create a particular atmosphere. Attorneys seem to love those browns and beiges based on the lawyers’ offices I’ve been in. I’m not sure that’s the message the leader of the free world wants to send out.
On the other hand, if this layout does make Obama tend to go to sleep, I’m all for that.